• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

When should we expect luma improvements in 4K Cinematic?

I´m sure you mean this one...
View attachment 12243

I think the disappointment is that he also liked the post quoted below. Since he seems to have read the thread without comment, we’re left to “read the tea leaves” and liking this post is not good IMHO, but I guess we’ll wait and see.

I’m curious if these people who see lack of responses have looked at other forums to see that K-scape folks are still active in posting.

As I said, I wouldn’t hold my breath on this “issue”.

They already responded on the issue once, not sure if another is needed or warranted. That’s my opinion just like those whose opinion think they deserve a response to perceived encode issues.
 
I think the disappointment is that he also liked the post quoted below.
Yeah, I noticed that. I wanted to emphasize the positive side a bit since some people over here always seem to jump on the maximum negative interpretation of posts and even likes...
 
For those who are anxious about improvement to 4K Cinematic luma sharpness, rest assured, Kaleidescape is actively working on that, and we will share updates as soon as we have them. Meanwhile, most customers agree that 4K Cinematic looks better in actual motion viewing than our 4:2:0 transcodes, so please enjoy.
 
For those who are anxious about improvement to 4K Cinematic luma sharpness, rest assured, Kaleidescape is actively working on that, and we will share updates as soon as we have them. Meanwhile, most customers agree that 4K Cinematic looks better in actual motion viewing than our 4:2:0 transcodes, so please enjoy.
When the fix is deployed, can you all add a “last updated on X date” to each file, or something similar so that we know if the 4KC file is pre or post fix?

Same thing for 4:2:0 encodes, if the title was last updated 3 years ago then we know it’s using the previous encoding sauce, if it’s been updated/released within past year then it’s with the improved encoding settings, and it’s very recent then it’s one of the newer 80Mbps avg encodes.
 
For those who are anxious about improvement to 4K Cinematic luma sharpness, rest assured, Kaleidescape is actively working on that, and we will share updates as soon as we have them. Meanwhile, most customers agree that 4K Cinematic looks better in actual motion viewing than our 4:2:0 transcodes, so please enjoy.
When the fix is deployed, can you all add a “last updated on X date” to each file, or something similar so that we know if the 4KC file is pre or post fix?
As an owner I have seen many requests for new metadata fields pass through this forum including custom title sorting, custom aspect ratios, alternate artwork, series, etc. I would prioritize all of these requests over an update date field and would hope K would do the same.

Beyond simple prioritization and value to users, I have concerns over the inference such a field presents and the confusion it will cause users. You appear to be under the impression that any encode before XX/XX/XX is "bad." But, RMarci's data never showed that. There were certainly poor encodes during a period of time but do you have a specific start date and end date? The same for 4KC. Are we expecting that someone is circulating the "good" and "bad" dates that users should be looking for?

What about when K "fixes" the recipe for encodes as of October 13th but there were unreleased titles in the pipeline that will release in November with the prior recipe? In my personal experience, I reported that "The Breakfast Club" was clearly based on outdates assets and reported it. It later got updated as part of the HD Compatibility project, but it was still the outdated asset. Much later it was updated with new assets delivering the quality I had experienced on disc and other digital stores. How does a new field address any of these cases?

Finally, how does an update field not cause more confusion? "Oh, this movie hasn't been updated since 2017. I don't want to buy it." Meanwhile, that encode may be the best available and clearly superior to any other source, but an old date -never before published- now infers something that's not true.

I believe the actual request is for an assurance that the encode on the K Store is the best available. And, frankly, no metadata field is going to provide that. As forum members we can review and report to each other and we can monitor the Movie Updates thread. The fact is K has always believed they were putting out quality products and if you don't agree you can report it and they'll investigate and respond.
 
As an owner I have seen many requests for new metadata fields pass through this forum including custom title sorting, custom aspect ratios, alternate artwork, series, etc. I would prioritize all of these requests over an update date field and would hope K would do the same.

Beyond simple prioritization and value to users, I have concerns over the inference such a field presents and the confusion it will cause users. You appear to be under the impression that any encode before XX/XX/XX is "bad." But, RMarci's data never showed that. There were certainly poor encodes during a period of time but do you have a specific start date and end date? The same for 4KC. Are we expecting that someone is circulating the "good" and "bad" dates that users should be looking for?

What about when K "fixes" the recipe for encodes as of October 13th but there were unreleased titles in the pipeline that will release in November with the prior recipe? In my personal experience, I reported that "The Breakfast Club" was clearly based on outdates assets and reported it. It later got updated as part of the HD Compatibility project, but it was still the outdated asset. Much later it was updated with new assets delivering the quality I had experienced on disc and other digital stores. How does a new field address any of these cases?

Finally, how does an update field not cause more confusion? "Oh, this movie hasn't been updated since 2017. I don't want to buy it." Meanwhile, that encode may be the best available and clearly superior to any other source, but an old date -never before published- now infers something that's not true.

I believe the actual request is for an assurance that the encode on the K Store is the best available. And, frankly, no metadata field is going to provide that. As forum members we can review and report to each other and we can monitor the Movie Updates thread. The fact is K has always believed they were putting out quality products and if you don't agree you can report it and they'll investigate and respond.
I had already laid out a more in depth process for this in another thread, along with various forms they could communicate a fix. Since tayloe had posted recently I just chose a simple option I have mentioned before on how to do this, but there are different ways it can be done, I just want a way to know.

We do know older encoding options were not up to par, and has been improved since, you could track the difference between how often an older one had issues vs post fixes where there rarely was one and it was UHD BR or better quality. They even mentioned a few times how they had updated the encoding or found X Y issue.

I simply disagree with your list of priorities because the one thing KS has always had above other options is convenience. Quality is what has been found to be lacking several times, so that should be the #1 priority. Fixing issues >>> adding extra bells and whistles. And I say that as someone that has wanted the HDR Metadata to be visible like on high end UHD Blu-Ray players.
 
I had already laid out a more in depth process for this in another thread, along with various forms they could communicate a fix. Since tayloe had posted recently I just chose a simple option I have mentioned before on how to do this, but there are different ways it can be done, I just want a way to know.

We do know older encoding options were not up to par, and has been improved since, you could track the difference between how often an older one had issues vs post fixes where there rarely was one and it was UHD BR or better quality. They even mentioned a few times how they had updated the encoding or found X Y issue.

I simply disagree with your list of priorities because the one thing KS has always had above other options is convenience. Quality is what has been found to be lacking several times, so that should be the #1 priority. Fixing issues >>> adding extra bells and whistles. And I say that as someone that has wanted the HDR Metadata to be visible like on high end UHD Blu-Ray players.
I think his point was knowing what “recipe” was used doesn’t tell you if it’s better or worse than the disc equivalent or the quality of the source/encode. The example was they could re-encode a bad source with the new settings and it still be worse than the disc/digital because it’s an old source and the opposite could also be true.

Also why is the HDR metadata important? Don’t lost projectors show in the info what metadata is being received? JVC certainly do, as do Lumagen and MadVR so I don’t know why it would need to be shown by the player as well when those will all be more accurate as they are realtime and sometimes the studios send broken HDR metadata.

If you mean the same realtime readout, definitely don’t want them to waste time and power on that, we don’t even have a scroll bar to fast forward/rewind which is far more useful
IMO and can’t be done by other devices.
 
I think his point was knowing what “recipe” was used doesn’t tell you if it’s better or worse than the disc equivalent or the quality of the source/encode. The example was they could re-encode a bad source with the new settings and it still be worse than the disc/digital because it’s an old source and the opposite could also be true.

Also why is the HDR metadata important? Don’t lost projectors show in the info what metadata is being received? JVC certainly do, as do Lumagen and MadVR so I don’t know why it would need to be shown by the player as well when those will all be more accurate as they are realtime and sometimes the studios send broken HDR metadata.

If you mean the same realtime readout, definitely don’t want them to waste time and power on that, we don’t even have a scroll bar to fast forward/rewind which is far more useful
IMO and can’t be done by other devices.
What metadata does the JVC use besides SDR, HDR and “mode”? New JVC user. Thanks.
 
The newer version of the Theater Optimizer in the NZ800/900 uses the metadata to determine what level of HDR processing it wants to use. This only pertains to the newer software for these specific JVC models. The rest ignore it.
 
The newer version of the Theater Optimizer in the NZ800/900 uses the metadata to determine what level of HDR processing it wants to use. This only pertains to the newer software for these specific JVC models. The rest ignore it.
Thanks for this Kriss, I was just about to PM you about that information. So the NZ8, of which I have one, doesn’t use any of the metadata to carry out its DTM calculations? Is there any point to using either of the “auto” HDR quantizer modes or is better to stick with one of the static ones and live with it?
 
I had already laid out a more in depth process for this in another thread, along with various forms they could communicate a fix... I simply disagree with your list of priorities because the one thing KS has always had above other options is convenience.
Totally understood and I've read your prior comments. Whether or not the requests are reasonable, I fear they are unrealistic and would point to prior K efforts to set expectations (HD Compatibility Efforts). Please know that I also sincerely value the work Rmarci did, I understand the sentiment behind your requests, and it's not my intention to argue with a fellow owner and forum member. I also want K to continue to improve and deliver the best encodes they can. We differ in priorities, I find current systems sufficient, I would rather see new resources spent elsewhere, and I believe this is a valid position K should be aware of.
 
The newer version of the Theater Optimizer in the NZ800/900 uses the metadata to determine what level of HDR processing it wants to use. This only pertains to the newer software for these specific JVC models. The rest ignore it.
So not the 700/500?
 
Thanks for this Kriss, I was just about to PM you about that information. So the NZ8, of which I have one, doesn’t use any of the metadata to carry out its DTM calculations? Is there any point to using either of the “auto” HDR quantizer modes or is better to stick with one of the static ones and live with it?
If you have a projector with the Theater Optimizer I would use the auto modes but make sure the info in the Theater Optimizer is correct and applied. The AUTO modes just decide what part of the manual range to use based on the frame/scene analysis. Neither is more right or wrong, they just are different options for how much compression you want. One compresses more but gives a brighter look to the whole frame. The other prioritizes more dynamic range but can look dimmer when compared directly but will have more punch with actual highlights.
 
Kaleidescape continually improves its transcode recipes. And when there has been a material improvement between an older recipe and newer ones, we retranscode. This is an ongoing exercise, prioritized by movie popularity on the platform, age of transcode, and availability of complete mezzanine assets.

Customers get update notifications whenever a currently downloaded movie has a video improvement made available, or a new audio track (e.g., Atmos) added, or a new format (e.g., 4K Cinematic) added.

And when you download, you're always getting the freshest version we have available.
 
Kaleidescape continually improves its transcode recipes. And when there has been a material improvement between an older recipe and newer ones, we retranscode. This is an ongoing exercise, prioritized by movie popularity on the platform, age of transcode, and availability of complete mezzanine assets.

Customers get update notifications whenever a currently downloaded movie has a video improvement made available, or a new audio track (e.g., Atmos) added, or a new format (e.g., 4K Cinematic) added.

And when you download, you're always getting the freshest version we have available.
Hate to be a stick in the mud, but I figured out pretty quickly how the K-Scape workflow progressed and updated its user base on statuses. It came as the result, mostly, from the now deleted thread because of the flow of information from K-Scape and Rmarci. As I’ve stated before I always appreciated his input.

If you require a 3rd party to evaluate every single piece of media for a USDA stamp of approval, some feel that it’s subjectively unnecessary, unreasonable and borderline unrealistic. How many products in hobbies across the board have we purchased that have been perfect?

Ultimately, it’s the end user’s responsibility to accept the product as is. My take is this is a constantly evolving and improving platform. That’s why I’m here. Excellent product that is easy to use and easy to consume. Perfect, far from it, warts and all.

Hopefully K-scape responses as of late can finally put this issue to bed. If they do decide to give us some form of log file, great, if not, darn. For me personally, it won’t diminish my enjoyment of the product or buy future 4KC/8K players in the future.

Thanks all. Have a splendid evening.
 
For those who are anxious about improvement to 4K Cinematic luma sharpness, rest assured, Kaleidescape is actively working on that, and we will share updates as soon as we have them. Meanwhile, most customers agree that 4K Cinematic looks better in actual motion viewing than our 4:2:0 transcodes, so please enjoy.
Hi @tayloe, thanks for replying to us here, it's greatly appreciated.

Given that there's general agreement that the 4K Cinematic encodes currently contain less detail (on a frame-by-frame basis, likely due to the reduced luma), you seem very confident (as others have also shared) that the new encodes do offer improvements in motion.

Could you, or one of your colleagues, help us understand why that is? Obviously there is the increased chroma (for many movies) and generally higher bitrate (some of which is necessary for the additional chroma data). But to my admittedly naive brain, it doesn't make sense that it would only improve the image in motion (I would expect it to be noticeable on a per frame basis too). What is causing the motion improvements? Are there aspects of the new recipes that are having an effect? Something else in the video format or encode that's changed? Is the new player able to do something that wasn't possible on the previous generation players/chips? Are there other factors at play? The additional chroma clearly isn't the whole story.

As enthusiasts, we're all excited to better understand our systems and what they're capable of. I know I'd appreciate any details you're willing to share. And we'd all like to be armed with specifics (within reason) when we're advocating for Kaleidescape to other potential customers. Almost every single person that experiences my theater asks about it...and I'd love to do better than "higher bitrate and better picture than UHD Bluray." And regardless, as you all make improvements, you should brag about it more :)

Thanks in advance.
 
“Our customers say it looks better in motion”

Rmarci.. love the guy, hate the guy, disagree with the guy…. Brought the data. If his data is or was wrong… I’ll kindly look at your data showing me he was incorrect… So show me your data proving Rmarci is wrong…🤷🏼
And now we see how losing him sucks.. he was an asset that improved this platform for free that benefited every one of us… he was ran off
 
Back
Top