• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

When should we expect luma improvements in 4K Cinematic?

So basically there is no point to Cinematic files other than to take up more hard drive space?
 
Last edited:
Please dont let this thread derail as well!

Let us all sing: "We are the world, we are gonna make it a better place, so keep on living".

Very good advice. Everyone PLEASE, keep posts related to the thread topic, not aiming at other members comments.

Jim
 
So basically there is no point to Cinematic files other than to take up more hard drive space?

As of now the cinematic encodes are softer… giving the appearance of smoother motion.
Regular encodes are sharper… that’s your difference. I personally like the motion on the cinematic… but I Iike the sharpness of the regular encodes more.
Sharper image… smaller file sizes.. the regular encodes is what I download which is disappointing.. but it is what it is…In the real world… no one I’ve put to the test can distinguish a regular encode vs cinematic vs disc consistently.
A regular encode with a cranked bit rate that matches the cinematic bit rate would be ideal..
as like the gentleman said a few posts back… chroma isn’t noticeable… luma is…
Cinematic has higher chroma taking up more bitrate that negatively impacts luma.. it’a a weird spot for Kaleidescape to be in because they marketed “higher chroma” … which results in a softer picture..
can it be fixed? Idk… taking an awfully long time..
a cranked bit rate regular chroma encode… would be the best ..for a sharper image and motion.. but that would go against what they are marketing with “chroma”.
 
How are you cranking bit rate? Or are you asking for cranked bit rate? If the data (IE Chroma or Luma) isn't any different, what benefit is there to a cranked bit rate?
As of now the cinematic encodes are softer… giving the appearance of smoother motion.
Regular encodes are sharper… that’s your difference. I personally like the motion on the cinematic… but I Iike the sharpness of the regular encodes more.
Sharper image… smaller file sizes.. the regular encodes is what I download which is disappointing.. but it is what it is…In the real world… no one I’ve put to the test can distinguish a regular encode vs cinematic vs disc consistently.
A regular encode with a cranked bit rate that matches the cinematic bit rate would be ideal..
as like the gentleman said a few posts back… chroma isn’t noticeable… luma is…
Cinematic has higher chroma taking up more bitrate that negatively impacts luma.. it’a a weird spot for Kaleidescape to be in because they marketed “higher chroma” … which results in a softer picture..
can it be fixed? Idk… taking an awfully long time..
a cranked bit rate regular chroma encode… would be the best ..for a sharper image and motion.. but that would go against what they are marketing with “chroma”.
 
How are you cranking bit rate? Or are you asking for cranked bit rate? If the data (IE Chroma or Luma) isn't any different, what benefit is there to a cranked bit rate?

I’m not cranking the bit rate.. I’m asking for the same bitrate on regular encodes that the cinematic encodes get.. why? the higher chroma is taking up most of the bitrate…negatively impacting luma.. which is why the cinematic encodes are less sharp than the regular encodes … while there is no benefit to higher chroma.

The regular encodes with a higher bit rate… would not only be more sharp… but also have improved motion. K made a mistake advertising higher chroma as it doesn’t make any kinda visible difference.. but robs the luma from the bit rate it needs… which is why cinematic encodes are more soft than the regular
 
Just hoping you can clarify something for us.

Is the situation that while you are still actively working on improving the luma channel, all 4K Cinematic encodes that have been and are currently being released are still using the “original recipe” and that when you have a definitive change in the process that you are happy with you will let us know and then start releasing new encodes with that singular “fix” after that point?

Or is this more of a “rolling fix” where you’ve already made some changes to what you are doing and more recent encodes have been using that but you are still working on perfecting the new process further so their will be further changes still to come?

Just trying to get an understanding of the basics of what you are doing with this.

Thanks.
You know, I thought this question was quite reasonable and respectful. And considering the premium cost to buy into this ecosystem, I would expect a respectful and reasonable question to get a respectful and reasonable response.

So, about that response to my question…
1792980267013.gif
 
You know, I thought this question was quite reasonable and respectful. And considering the premium cost to buy into this ecosystem, I would expect a respectful and reasonable question to get a respectful and reasonable response.

So, about that response to my question…
View attachment 12497
This is getting old. I highly doubt these type of demands on an owner's forum are going to have the effect you may, or may not, be expecting. This sounds like an entitled teenager expecting McDonalds to change its menu to vegan. McDonalds isn't going to answer and you're not entitled to it. If you don't like the product, stop eating it. Judge Smails - fitting.
 
This is getting old. I highly doubt these type of demands on an owner's forum are going to have the effect you may, or may not, be expecting. This sounds like an entitled teenager expecting McDonalds to change its menu to vegan. McDonalds isn't going to answer and you're not entitled to it. If you don't like the product, stop eating it. Judge Smails - fitting.
Oh, for F’s sake.
 
Oh, for F’s sake.

You are only getting that response because ppl paid a significant amount of money and bought into the marketing and do not want to admit to themselves downloading a cinematic encode will take longer, take up more space and be Less sharp than a regular encode. K admitted the issues with the Luma… and it’s awesome they did, nothing wrong with asking these questions and expecting the product to match the marketing claims. I love my K system… but I wish they would simply acknowledge or realize the chroma bump doesn’t improve the picture, it only takes bit rate away from the luma..
but like I said above…. It puts them in a spot because their marketing is glorifying Chroma.. and it’s simply not noticeable while Luma is. Again.. I’m confident they’ll fix it…I waited a year for them to fix the Strato V’s defects… but then we had someone verifying what they were doing and holding them accountable…
 
You are only getting that response because ppl paid a significant amount of money and bought into the marketing and do not want to admit to themselves downloading a cinematic encode will take longer, take up more space and be Less sharp than a regular encode. K admitted the issues with the Luma… and it’s awesome they did, nothing wrong with asking these questions and expecting the product to match the marketing claims. I love my K system… but I wish they would simply acknowledge or realize the chroma bump doesn’t improve the picture, it only takes bit rate away from the luma..
but like I said above…. It puts them in a spot because their marketing is glorifying Chroma.. and it’s simply not noticeable while Luma is. Again.. I’m confident they’ll fix it…I waited a year for them to fix the Strato V’s defects… but then we had someone verifying what they were doing and holding them accountable…
I don’t want to wade into this again, I only have this thread on my watch list for the updates from KScape. What I will say though is you weren’t saying that before when doing your own testing and it’s sad to see that you have watched and compared something yourself, been really happy and then been convinced that the luma difference is terrible and the Cinematic stuff is much worse.
 
Still actively working on it.

Hello @tayloe ,

I’m kind of surprised we haven’t heard anything further about this yet. I thought it would be a simple encoding tweak, but, admittedly, I am not knowledgeable about the technical aspects of this. Please let us know how it’s going. Thank you.
 
Hello @tayloe ,

I’m kind of surprised we haven’t heard anything further about this yet. I thought it would be a simple encoding tweak, but, admittedly, I am not knowledgeable about the technical aspects of this. Please let us know how it’s going. Thank you.

There are two parts to this, a transcode change and a code change.

Transcodes based on the new recipe started rolling out on 10/23. All 4K Cinematic releases and updates since then are based on the new recipe. We have about 50 movies done. It will probably take six months to finish retranscoding all the Cinematics.

The code change is done, but testing won't done in time for the upcoming kOS release. We expect it to go out in the 1Q27 kOS release.
 
There are two parts to this, a transcode change and a code change.

Transcodes based on the new recipe started rolling out on 10/23. All 4K Cinematic releases and updates since then are based on the new recipe. We have about 50 movies done. It will probably take six months to finish retranscoding all the Cinematics.

The code change is done, but testing won't done in time for the upcoming kOS release. We expect it to go out in the 1Q27 kOS release.
Do these new recipes introduce any enhancements to 4K cinematic Dolby Vision, or only to 4K cinematic HDR?
 
There are two parts to this, a transcode change and a code change.

Transcodes based on the new recipe started rolling out on 10/23. All 4K Cinematic releases and updates since then are based on the new recipe. We have about 50 movies done. It will probably take six months to finish retranscoding all the Cinematics.

The code change is done, but testing won't done in time for the upcoming kOS release. We expect it to go out in the 1Q27 kOS release.

Thanks for the quick and informative reply! I’m sure 1Q27 is later than everyone was hoping, but with new transcodes and retranscodes happening in the meantime, we should really “hit the ground running” when the kOS update happens.
 
Thanks for the quick and informative reply! I’m sure 1Q27 is later than everyone was hoping, but with new transcodes and retranscodes happening in the meantime, we should really “hit the ground running” when the kOS update happens.

Part of the benefit is immediate with the new transcode; additional benefit comes with the upcoming code change.
 
Part of the benefit is immediate with the new transcode; additional benefit comes with the upcoming code change.

Oh, nice! I didn’t realize that.

I’m sure there are going to be users interested in seeing any “before-and-after” shots showing the type of changes being done with the new transcodes recipe, and maybe even including your internal beta kOS. Have you considered sharing anything like that?
 
Back
Top