• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

When should we expect luma improvements in 4K Cinematic?

“Our customers say it looks better in motion”

Rmarci.. love the guy, hate the guy, disagree with the guy…. Brought the data. If his data is or was wrong… I’ll kindly look at your data showing me he was incorrect… So show me your data proving Rmarci is wrong…🤷🏼
And now we see how losing him sucks.. he was an asset that improved this platform for free that benefited every one of us… he was ran off
Oh c´mon - give it a break...
I think is applicable to more than just me
 
Kaleidescape continually improves its transcode recipes. And when there has been a material improvement between an older recipe and newer ones, we retranscode. This is an ongoing exercise, prioritized by movie popularity on the platform, age of transcode, and availability of complete mezzanine assets.

Customers get update notifications whenever a currently downloaded movie has a video improvement made available, or a new audio track (e.g., Atmos) added, or a new format (e.g., 4K Cinematic) added.

And when you download, you're always getting the freshest version we have available.
Thanks for keeping us in the loop.

I infer from this that a re-transcode doesn't necessarily trigger the Movie Updated notification?
Did I infer incorrectly?

I'd take an automatic re-download for a re-transcoded file such that I always know that my download is the "freshest" available in lieu of an update notification. That is, I would always want the latest transcode even if the movie assets don't change (i.e. no new video, extras or audio tracks).
 
Thanks for keeping us in the loop.

I infer from this that a re-transcode doesn't necessarily trigger the Movie Updated notification?
Did I infer incorrectly?

I'd take an automatic re-download for a re-transcoded file such that I always know that my download is the "freshest" available in lieu of an update notification. That is, I would always want the latest transcode even if the movie assets don't change (i.e. no new video, extras or audio tracks).
Re-transcodes trigger the movie updated notification if you have the current version downloaded on your system prior to the new version being made available.
 
I think his point was knowing what “recipe” was used doesn’t tell you if it’s better or worse than the disc equivalent or the quality of the source/encode. The example was they could re-encode a bad source with the new settings and it still be worse than the disc/digital because it’s an old source and the opposite could also be true.

Also why is the HDR metadata important? Don’t lost projectors show in the info what metadata is being received? JVC certainly do, as do Lumagen and MadVR so I don’t know why it would need to be shown by the player as well when those will all be more accurate as they are realtime and sometimes the studios send broken HDR metadata.

If you mean the same realtime readout, definitely don’t want them to waste time and power on that, we don’t even have a scroll bar to fast forward/rewind which is far more useful
IMO and can’t be done by other devices.
Here is the more detailed step I had proposed in the closed thread, just in case:

"Movies and tv shows could have title update numbers that let you know, for example for 4:2:0 encodes:

Title update 2.0 or higher means it’s using the latest encode processes deployed months go.

Title update 2.5 or higher means it’s been upgraded to the 80Mbps avg bitrate tayloe mentioned they were going to do.

For 4KC they could do the same, 2.0 or higher denotes it has the luma detail fix.

“But Jin that’s a lot of work to add that to the store!” I already hear you say. Fine, I’m not saying they will do it next week, but in the meantime post a list of 4:2:0 titles that were previously re-encoded and a weekly post with “the following titles have been updated this week”.

The date updated one is just likely a quicker and easier thing to implement than making their internal version numbers visible for all titles and explaining what those are, although we saw it happen with one user's Man of Steel download that had the version number and bitrate indicating it was a new 80Mbps encode. Alternatively they can have a thread with a weekly post on what's been updated to the latest recipe/fix, which would then be searchable. Instead of the generic "audio/video improvement" the store has.

And yes that doesn't guarantee quality/issue free title, for that we would need in depth reviewers but we don't have that anymore like we have with discs. But if you were keeping up with the quality thread, you saw that after the various encoding improvements, the quality success rate was much, much higher; and a title having an issue was really an outlier. So it would still be very useful for people to be able to buy with confidence.
 
Here is the more detailed step I had proposed in the closed thread, just in case:



The date updated one is just likely a quicker and easier thing to implement than making their internal version numbers visible for all titles and explaining what those are, although we saw it happen with one user's Man of Steel download that had the version number and bitrate indicating it was a new 80Mbps encode. Alternatively they can have a thread with a weekly post on what's been updated to the latest recipe/fix, which would then be searchable. Instead of the generic "audio/video improvement" the store has.

And yes that doesn't guarantee quality/issue free title, for that we would need in depth reviewers but we don't have that anymore like we have with discs. But if you were keeping up with the quality thread, you saw that after the various encoding improvements, the quality success rate was much, much higher; and a title having an issue was really an outlier. So it would still be very useful for people to be able to buy with confidence.
An interesting thought, although I would imagine for most users that would create more confusion as to what it actually means.

It would need to be a separate thing to the main user interface if it were going to be a thing IMO.

What disc reviewers do you mean? The only ones I ever read were on Blu-ray.com and High Def Digest and nobody ever does any frame by frame analysis.
 
An interesting thought, although I would imagine for most users that would create more confusion as to what it actually means.

It would need to be a separate thing to the main user interface if it were going to be a thing IMO.

What disc reviewers do you mean? The only ones I ever read were on Blu-ray.com and High Def Digest and nobody ever does any frame by frame analysis.
Well he still does on YT, but The Digital Bits, High Def Dighest and Blu-Ray have a keener eye than the average KS user. Like being able to tell the Arrow version of Thief was slightly better than the Criterion one (likely owing to the Arrow one being done by Fidelity in Motion).
 
Feels weird that a literal whole month later, you a) still can't make 4K Cinematic an upgrade rather than a downgrade relative to your normal 4K files, and b) are still releasing 4K Cinematic files with the inferior-to-regular-4K encodes at a good clip.

It's getting hard to avoid the feeling that you'd rather let the criticisms blow over, and get the praise from people who like the "smooth" look of lower-grain files, and see it as an improvement over disc/regular-4K. Especially because I suspect a fixed version would put things back into the area where it's perceptually much more similar to regular 4K, and won't get that naive "wow" reaction.

(Just popping in to check on things after watching a Linus Tech Tips video where he raved about that smooth, low-grain look, which made me wonder if there was any progress on fixing the thing that he and so many others apparently love. Apparently not!)
 
Feels weird that a literal whole month later, you a) still can't make 4K Cinematic an upgrade rather than a downgrade relative to your normal 4K files, and b) are still releasing 4K Cinematic files with the inferior-to-regular-4K encodes at a good clip.

It's getting hard to avoid the feeling that you'd rather let the criticisms blow over, and get the praise from people who like the "smooth" look of lower-grain files, and see it as an improvement over disc/regular-4K. Especially because I suspect a fixed version would put things back into the area where it's perceptually much more similar to regular 4K, and won't get that naive "wow" reaction.

(Just popping in to check on things after watching a Linus Tech Tips video where he raved about that smooth, low-grain look, which made me wonder if there was any progress on fixing the thing that he and so many others apparently love. Apparently not!)

Interesting part is, it seems the increase in chroma is what is impacting the Luma…. And the colors are not improved over the regular encodes, there is zero noticeable difference, I’ve not seen anyone even mention they notice a difference in colors, so what you currently get is a softer image, that appears smoother in motion with a much larger file size.

We would be better off with the regular encodes with a cranked bit rate.
 
Still actively working on it.
Just hoping you can clarify something for us.

Is the situation that while you are still actively working on improving the luma channel, all 4K Cinematic encodes that have been and are currently being released are still using the “original recipe” and that when you have a definitive change in the process that you are happy with you will let us know and then start releasing new encodes with that singular “fix” after that point?

Or is this more of a “rolling fix” where you’ve already made some changes to what you are doing and more recent encodes have been using that but you are still working on perfecting the new process further so their will be further changes still to come?

Just trying to get an understanding of the basics of what you are doing with this.

Thanks.
 
Feels weird that a literal whole month later, you a) still can't make 4K Cinematic an upgrade rather than a downgrade relative to your normal 4K files, and b) are still releasing 4K Cinematic files with the inferior-to-regular-4K encodes at a good clip.

It's getting hard to avoid the feeling that you'd rather let the criticisms blow over, and get the praise from people who like the "smooth" look of lower-grain files, and see it as an improvement over disc/regular-4K. Especially because I suspect a fixed version would put things back into the area where it's perceptually much more similar to regular 4K, and won't get that naive "wow" reaction.

(Just popping in to check on things after watching a Linus Tech Tips video where he raved about that smooth, low-grain look, which made me wonder if there was any progress on fixing the thing that he and so many others apparently love. Apparently not!)
That makes it sound like an either/or choice. I hope that's not the case, but if it is it raises a difficult question. What should a responsible business choose, the one that's more technically correct or the one that the majority of customers prefer?
 
That makes it sound like an either/or choice. I hope that's not the case, but if it is it raises a difficult question. What should a responsible business choose, the one that's more technically correct or the one that the majority of customers prefer?

I also hope it's not either/or, but the fact that it's taken them a month and they still don't have a solution and they keep acting like it's not a problem in multiple ways makes me suspect that it might be.

It's funny, because I bought the Strato K 100% expecting Cinematic to be something that was probably invisible 95% of the time, and where only obsessive pixel-peepers would care about it, but where it would unquestionably be eliminating that last 1% of technical flaws. And then I thought that they'd made a mistake at first, which they'd quickly correct and return us to that conception of the product. But instead it feels like it's maybe the video equivalent of an "audiophile" product, the tube amp or vinyl of movie encodes, giving you warmth/creaminess/whatever in a way that's perceptually pleasing even as it's technically less correct.

I hope this is wrong, and they're dedicated to technical correctness above pleasantness, and will improve the encodes to be truer to the masters even if that means that most people can't tell the difference between them and regular 4K, unlike with the smoothed-out soft versions. But it feels like if that was their goal, they could have hit it by now...
 
I also just recently purchased a Strato K over a much cheaper open box Strato E on the promise of superior Cinematic quality.
One week after my purchase this issue was discovered.
I kept my pre-order for the K
I would much prefer my movie files truer to source at the highest quality. Even if that means it’s super grainy.

I have been impressed by what I have seen on the Strato E. But the K promises more.
As of now they have my belief it will be fixed or properly addressed.
I really hope I don’t sour on Kaleidescape as a company.
 
Still actively working on it.
Thank you for the response, and for engaging on this in the forum - it’s appreciated.

One point of clarification: is the in-work fix at the player/software level (and would therefore apply globally across all affected titles), or is it at the individual title level (requiring a new encode and re-download for each impacted movie)? Trying to understand whether this resolves on its own with an update or whether affected titles will need to be re-downloaded.

Apologies if this has already been covered - appreciate the patience.
 
Thank you for the response, and for engaging on this in the forum - it’s appreciated.

One point of clarification: is the in-work fix at the player/software level (and would therefore apply globally across all affected titles), or is it at the individual title level (requiring a new encode and re-download for each impacted movie)? Trying to understand whether this resolves on its own with an update or whether affected titles will need to be re-downloaded.

Apologies if this has already been covered - appreciate the patience.

It’s the encodes. According to the infamous RMARCI when he discovered this issue, he said he believed that the chroma being higher takes up significantly more bit rate, leaving less for the luma… which is why the image is more soft than the standard encodes… I don’t personally know. I do know there is no difference in the colors between regular encodes and cinematic with the higher chroma..
I haven’t seen many ppl claim to be able to see any difference in the colors between the encodes…
A regular encode with a cranked bit rate theoretically should produce a significantly better image than a cinematic encode… as the regular encodes are sharper as is. But..,Kaleidescape has been advertising “chroma” as one of the main draws to the cinematic content.. although no one can see a difference in “chroma” and only seeing a difference in sharpness or smoothness in motion.
 
It’s the encodes. According to the infamous RMARCI when he discovered this issue, he said he believed that the chroma being higher takes up significantly more bit rate, leaving less for the luma… which is why the image is more soft than the standard encodes… I don’t personally know. I do know there is no difference in the colors between regular encodes and cinematic with the higher chroma..
I haven’t seen many ppl claim to be able to see any difference in the colors between the encodes…
A regular encode with a cranked bit rate theoretically should produce a significantly better image than a cinematic encode… as the regular encodes are sharper as is. But..,Kaleidescape has been advertising “chroma” as one of the main draws to the cinematic content.. although no one can see a difference in “chroma” and only seeing a difference in sharpness or smoothness in motion.

From my limited comparisons, the colors can be significantly improved.
 
Flipping back and forth… I can’t see a lick of difference in the colors… none. I notice the picture is softer in cinematic…. And the motion is smoother.
The regular encodes are sharper, that’s with a lower bit rate and smaller file sizes. When I’ve blind tested
My friends… watching or pausing and flipping back and forth… they guess. They never get it consistently correct.
I’ve noticed movies with film grain is where the smoothness and the softer image is the most noticeable. I’d love to see a regular encode with the cinematic bit rate…
 
Quite simply, if the colors are more vibrant in Cinematic files (they aren’t) then something is significantly wrong with either one of the encodes. Additional chroma resolution does not affect color saturation/vibrancy at all, just results in slightly sharper detail, but again, luma detail is far more noticeable than chroma detail to humans.
 
Back
Top