• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

Popcorn Machines

ha. it's not hard to up your game considerably. i can make a batch in about 6 minutes start to finish... truly. and the difference in taste is dramatic. Hope you'll give it a shot... 🍿
Thanks, Josh! Will try it. Happy Thanksgiving!
 
Josh I have had a Whirley Pop for about 4 years now and it is great. I thought about getting a machine, but I always thought the clean up of them would be a huge hassle. The Whirley Pop is pretty easy to clean up. Never knew about the Stainless one, I will have to dig into the Stainless and try. Thanks for the info. Great conversation everyone. 🍿
 
I have both a traditional popcorn machine located in the basement (directly outside of my dedicated theater) and also have a version of the Whirley Pop that works on our induction range (I think it's stainless). I've had both types for over 20 years, and although the popcorn machine is cool and nostalgic for when we have company or my sons' friends over, the stove stop version is much easier to use and clean. The end result tastes identical between the two cooking methods.

But the dedicated popper is not bad to maintain either, just takes a bit more effort. You also don't need to clean it up right after the movie. I usually don't get to it for a few days and just use a wet microfiber cloth to wipe it out. I have a machine with the "old maid" tray below, which makes cleaning up the unpopped kernels very easy. And the tray for that is stainless steel so easy to clean in the dishwasher.
 
Now things are getting serious. I want to get a real popcorn maker for my theater. I am looking at the 8 oz options from Paragon likely either the Theater or Professional. I know they are quite a bit more expensive than some of the other machines out there, but the reviews all seem to say it is the last machine you will ever need to buy and worth it. What thoughts or experiences do you have with your popcorn machines for your theater and what size did you go with? I'm leaning towards a little bigger because it might get used for the occasional scout or neighborhood function as well.

For those with the popcorn machines, do you use the pre-portioned packs or make your own blend? Any recommendations there as well?
Purchased a paragon 6 oz machine about 20 years ago and it’s been going strong. Cleaning it was never an issue or caused any heartache. We used many brands of the premade packs for the last 20 years but recently had to switch to our own kernals, coconut oil and flavacol due to my wife developing an allergy to something in the packs that recently changed ( she is allergic to dairy). Other than the convenience the popcorn tastes just as good as long as buy good ingredients.
 
After recently finding and reading this thread, I purchased and tried a Whirley-Pop Popcorn popper (stainless Steel, stove-top model, hand-wash only). Before this purchase, I used a Cuisinart 4 QT Saucepan and lid (stainless steel, dishwasher safe). Initially, I was reluctant to purchase a Whirley-Pop due to the hand-wash requirement. I also looked at the Popsmith popper that is dishwasher-safe, but this Whirley-Pop was 1/3 the price of the Popsmith; the Whirley-Pop design had been time tested (since the 1980s); and the Popsmith design seemed to be lacking in a few areas IMHO (venting and hand position for cranking).

After following the instructions to wash the new Whirley-Pop, season the pan, and then making a test batch last week, this past Saturday night I tried out the Whirley-Pop *officially* for our Saturday movie night!

I used the same popcorn recipe that I used previously:
- 1/2 cup Eden Foods Organic popcorn (Eden Foods)
- about 1 tablespoon Spectrum Organic Canola Oil (just enough oil to cover the bottom of the pot)
- Eden Foods Sea Salt sprinkled on top after popping (Eden Foods)

My thoughts/opinions?
I followed the directions that came with the Whirley-Pop and I was impressed that all the popcorn kernels popped and that the kernels seemed to pop larger than when I used my usual methodology. It was interesting, that the same 1/2 cup of popcorn that previously filled my 4 quart pot, now fills the 6 quart Whirley-Pop! The popped kernels were larger and I think this is due to popping at higher heat levels. "Cranking" the popper during cooking was easy, just as long as I secured the lid to the pan before adding the popcorn kernels. For my test run, I made the mistake of putting both the oil and popcorn into the pan and then securing the lid to the pan. This must have caught some kernels under the stirring mechanism and it made cranking difficult. My official batch, made with the lid secured first, cranked smoothly as expected. Popcorn flavor was excellent and was not soggy at all, just like my previous methodology, but now with the bonus that the kernels were larger!

Although I used a higher heat level than I normally do, the cooking process was definitely longer than 3 minutes (the advertised cooking time). For me, it was more like 5-6 minutes (it took about 4 minutes just to start the popping). I had previously used a medium-low temperature (5.5/10) and for this Whirley-Pop batch I used the Whirley-Pop suggested medium-high temperature (7/10). I think that for me and my electric flat-top range, the stainless steel pot base takes longer to heat up.

Cleaning the Whirley-Pop was less odious than I thought it would be, and I agree with @josh that the clean up is not an issue. I would describe the cleanup as minimal, quick, and easy.

Going forward, I will try less oil (scant tablespoon) and a higher temperature (8/10) on my range to try to decrease the cooking time.

Looking at the Popsmith, without actually purchasing and trying it, the design appears to be lacking sufficient venting. It has no vents on the top (hot air rises!). I saw only one vent on the side of the lid of the Popsmith. I would guess that they placed the vent on the side of the top because the user cranks the Popsmith with their hand above the top, and if there were a vent or vents on the top, then your hand would be burned by the hot steam coming out of the popper. Also, IMHO the Popsmith design with the crank on the top/lid, could create a situation where the heat from the pan could make your hand warm/hot since, while cranking, your hand is right over the lid and, as we know, hot air rises! Conversely, the Whirley-Pop has 4 top vents (plus gaps in the top/lid). Venting appeared adequate to allow the steam/moisture from cooking to escape. Also, while cranking the Whirley-Pop during cooking, your hands are off to the side and are not close to the heat rising up off of the pan.

In summary, I agree with @josh's extensive popcorn popper review and his JoshReviews® helped convince me to give this popper a try. I'm now a convert!

Overall, I'm happy with the Whirley-Pop and I look forward to using it in the future!
 
Glad to hear it's gone well!

For my test run, I made the mistake of putting both the oil and popcorn into the pan and then securing the lid to the pan.
I don't understand this part... yes you definitely should not have the whole lid with stirring thing off of the pot when you put in the popcorn! But that's exactly why the whirley pop lid has ONE side of the top hatch that secures to the pot (doesn't open, secures the whole lid along with the two clips at the "top" and "bottom" of the lid ("bottom" meaning where the handle is, and that clip has a "thumb release" to make getting the lid off easier when it's clean up time) and the other flappy-side with a knob that has no clip-latch... it lifts up and down easily and is for adding your ingredients and for checking the state of the popcorn.

As for oil, it's all personal preference, but i use and prefer more than you're using. For me, it's 1 rounded tablespoon of the solid yellow coconut oils when i'm doing full "movie theater" recipe, or just 1 regular tablespoon of oil (avocado or peanut lately) when i'm popping 1/3 cup of kernels, and 1.5 to 2 tablespoons of oil when i up it to 1/2 cup of kernels.

i can understand wishing to make your a little healthier. (but that said, my popcorn never comes out oily or soggy).

Good luck, keep us informed of your progress and your perfected recipe.

And as someone who bought and tried (and shelved) PopSmith, i think your analysis is right. top crank location prevented them from safely adding top vents... and that does affect sogginess of your popcorn. venting is key. Whirly pop does it right with the crank on the handle, but i'm sure that's patented so popsmith had to do it their own way, which led to compromises. In the end, it's just inferior to Whirley Pop in what really matters - quality of the popped corn. Maybe cleanup is slightly easier, but WP cleanup is by no means burdensome!
 
My popsmith has never been soggy. When complete, I immediately crack the lid up and let out steam. There is quite a bit of steam that comes out with the top/side venting. But I also just make 1/3 cup of kernels, so maybe this minimizes what you are tasting. When done, put the whole thing in the dishwasher….

This guy can’t tell any difference…

 
My popsmith has never been soggy. When complete, I immediately crack the lid up and let out steam. There is quite a bit of steam that comes out with the top/side venting. But I also just make 1/3 cup of kernels, so maybe this minimizes what you are tasting. When done, put the whole thing in the dishwasher….

This guy can’t tell any difference…

I’m with you. I love the Popsmith and have zero complaints.
 
I’ve owned a Gold Medal Model 2660GT with a red cart like this since 1998. Gold Medal is the #1 popcorn machine supplier in the world and are headquartered in Cincinnati where I lived for 25 years. I use a Megapop kit that has the flavored coconut oil, popcorn and Flavacol prepackaged. My machine has worked flawlessly for 27 years of heavy home theater use. It also looks great. I’ve experimented with other oils and popcorn but keep coming back to Megapop. This machine uses the 6 oz popcorn + 2 oz coconut oil kit.

1765900920224.jpeg
 
WOW! Very impressive!
💯 on the snacks displays and offerings!

The only SLIGHT/TINY improvement would be the popcorn machine orientation on that model. You've got what's called a "front-counter" popper model (graphics are on the opposite side of where typical access to the popped corn is) next to a "back-counter" topping machine dispenser (graphics and usage intended for the same side of the machine). Manufacturers typically offer their models of poppers and dispensers in both versions - front-counter and back-counter when you place an order.

"Back counter" models are meant either for user self-serve, or for staff-serve when the machine is behind the staff... ("on a back counter"). "Front Counter" machines are meant for visual display facing the customer but access on the opposite side of the machine for staff standing behind the front counter to access and serve the treat. But now we're into deep concession-device nerd topics here and I'm probably one of the few people who would ever notice it, and only after being completely blown away by the incredible equipment, graphics, and customization you've pulled off here! 🙌
 
Last edited:
WOW! Very impressive!
💯 on the snacks displays and offerings!

The only SLIGHT/TINY improvement would be the popcorn machine orientation on that model. You've got what's called a "front-counter" popper model (graphics are on the opposite side of where typical access to the popped corn is) next to a "back-counter" topping machine dispenser (graphics and usage intended for the same side of the machine). Manufacturers typically offer their models of poppers and dispensers in both versions - front-counter and back-counter when you place an order.

"Back counter" models are meant either for user self-serve, or for staff-serve when the machine is behind the staff... ("on a back counter"). "Front Counter" machines are meant for visual display facing the customer but access on the opposite side of the machine for staff standing behind the front counter to access and serve the treat. But now we're into deep concession-device nerd topics here and I'm probably one of the few people who would ever notice it, and only after being completely blown away by the incredible equipment, graphics, and customization you've pulled off here! 🙌
Josh you are the expert on this stuff for sure. I know you love the whirlypop but if I was to buy a BACK COUNTER machine what would be your recommendation for brand and model? Want a decent size one. Rough idea of what they run for? Up for any and all suggestions 👍🏻 🍿
 
We have signage identifying popcorn from the side as well. When this one goes I will take your advice though. 😊

IMG_0830.jpeg


IMG_0828.jpeg
 
Josh you are the expert on this stuff for sure. I know you love the whirlypop but if I was to buy a BACK COUNTER machine what would be your recommendation for brand and model? Want a decent size one. Rough idea of what they run for? Up for any and all suggestions 👍🏻 🍿
The Paragon machines are generally top quality, long lasting. Pretty sure the company is made up completely of laid off Maytag workers from when they closed a plant. These folks know mechanical appliances.

Fun fact. Their plant is about 15 miles from the SeymourAV shop.

 
Back
Top