Furnace Inferno
Well-known member
I guess it depends how you want to rate though because there are some people who think anything with film grain looks bad. Pretty sure they rate based on how faithful it is to the source not whether the source looks good.I really don't trust those reviews lately because I think they should be much lower in a lot of cases than what they give. For instance, the Minority Report 4K version didn't look all that great to me but it got 4.8 out of 5 for video. I'm referring to the bluray.com ratings.
Look at the 28 days later Blu-ray review video score. Other than the last minute which is actually in HD, compared to any other Blu-ray it wouldn’t get any higher than 0.5/5 and that’s being generous because it’s literally just an SD movie. No fault of the disc and everything to do with the source being limited to that but rewatching because of the sequels I forgot just how bad SD is!
They are reviewing the disc rather than the outright visual quality.