• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

When should we expect luma improvements in 4K Cinematic?

Working on the spreadsheet I maintain and noticed GotG 2 in 4K_C DV had an update sometime since original roll out:
I can't speak to the quality of the encode, but the file size got bigger...enough to where the video should have picked up 9-10 mbps on average. They're definitely pushing up the video bitrate with the recent releases. All of these are at the top when sorted by approximate video bitrate:

Napoleon Dynamite - No Hard Feelings - Hell or High Water - Hitch - Hacksaw Ridge - T2 - Twilight Breaking Dawn 2 - Once Upon a Time in Hollywood - Twilight - TRON: Legacy - Dirty Dancing - Interview with the Vampire - Conjuring: Last Rites - GotG 2

Makes me think they realized the SoC had more capability "in the tank" reliably. Napoleon Dynamite should be over 125 mbps (average) for video alone - a new record. 🫡

I'm still working in my spare time, only made it from A-H so far.
I reported KS that GotG had a big problem..
The movie was in some scènes unwachtable because of black crush.
Colours where off. I provided them with photos and timestamps. Within 3 hours of the first mail from me to them, they answert.
Within a week the file has turned from unwachtable to reference!!
Thanks again KS!
 
You can sit there and say it’s devolving all you want but it’s not. You can deflect all you want as well. My points are no less valid. I think people standing around pointing at the clock is unreasonable and unproductive. I’m keeping it civil and just ask that you answer my questions honestly.

So my next question is, when do you expect a reasonable response and what would be your next step? Constantly posting “where’s my update” isn’t productive.

What will those wanting an update do when the proposed deadline passes and what was requested hasn’t been delivered? Again, let’s be reasonable.

Some of us feel this is an unproductive conversation and continued conversation in the topic just proves your point, that it can and probably will devolve.

K-scape has already seen this post and reacted to some posts if memory serves. So, again, what do you expect?

I’d also ask one more question if you. Is this directly affecting your enjoyment of the product? If so how?

Thanks.
I'll answer simply, then leave it here. What do I expect? Only what the thread title asks - a status on the luma improvements to 4K Cinematic. Kaleidescape already acknowledged the issue; I'm just interested in where the fix stands. That's it.
 
Oh c´mon - give it a break...
I’d request the toe tappers to do the same but let’s keep it reasonable. I think my question is entirely reasonable amongst adults. Your response is borderline.

We’ve already had reports of improved products and responses to emails as has been documented from end users.

Obviously, that isn’t good enough and that my friend is unreasonable.
 
I was certainly optimistic that they would when I asked my question on 9/21, but... it's been two full weeks and there is no response at all, not even a "we're still working on figuring out timing" or anything. I very much hope you're correct, but I'm starting to fear that their comms strategy here is to let things blow over and not comment again.

Which, to allow myself a little cynicism, is probably an optimal strategy from some perspectives. The thread with the analysis is gone from the internet, so there's no longer any record of the problems, and most people are still acting like 4KC is an unquestionable upgrade, with complaints going back to the "when will this title be upgraded to 4KC?" Why bother saying anything and risk stirring up another hornet's nest, especially if what they'd say is -- as I increasingly suspect -- the unpopular thing that there are no plans to re-encode already-encoded movies.

Unfortunately, that leaves people like me in the lurch. Right now, it's well established that the ideal strategy is to download the superior 4K encodes and to ignore the inferior 4KC ones. I'm willing to believe that this will change at some point in the future, but if Kscape is unwilling to say when it will change or for which movies, and nobody is doing any kind of analysis that could independently demonstrate it... do I just keep downloading the base 4K movies forever, throwing away the whole reason I spent extra for the Strato K over the E? Do I decide that after some point from now (next month? 3 months? 6 months?) I should download new releases in 4KC but still keep 4K for back-catalog stuff that will never get updated? Is there a point at which I should expect the back catalog to be updated?

I genuinely don't know. I just want to use this machine in the best way possible, and for them to give me the information to let me do this, but instead I'm left guessing, because -- I guess? -- they just don't want to talk about it. It's frustrating.

Fair enough, and I'm not looking to argue it in circles. For me a "real question" is simple: a status on 4KC encode plans. That's it.

Honestly, this exchange is a decent example of the dynamic I mentioned. Someone asks for a straightforward status update, and the thread fills with reasons the ask is unreasonable, debates over methodology, "nobody's forcing you to buy it," and so on - everything except the simple thing being asked for. That's exactly how a topic gets talked in circles until it quietly dies.

"Nobody's forcing you to buy it" is true of any product and any complaint, so it doesn't really move things. People asking a company they've invested in for a status update isn't entitlement - it's normal, and it's easy to satisfy. That's the whole ask.

The 4KC problem Rmarci identified is a legitimate issue. @tayloe acknowledged it and said they would address it. I was hoping for more updates after that too. The topic isn’t going to go away until it’s resolved. In real world viewing, 4KC still compares favorably to standard 4K IMO, but this technical encoding deficiency has honestly put a damper on 4KC, and the sooner K-scape reclaims the high ground on this the better.

I have no desire currently to buy a K player. Seems to me it was a 1st gen device lacking in a couple of areas. If they come out with a 2nd gen that is a bit tighter, I’m going to evaluate it, wait and see how good it is then make a decision.

Am I missing anything not having a K? Maybe.

As far as Interstellar goes, yeah seems as if the 4KC was a better encode than the other versions, subjectively.

I was shocked to learn you don’t even own a Strato K, but seem compelled to constantly insert yourself in the 4KC discussion. Also, how can you weigh in on a subjective discussion of the Interstellar 4KC without the ability to view 4KC content?

Oh c´mon - give it a break...

Amen to that!
 
The 4KC problem Rmarci identified is a legitimate issue. @tayloe acknowledged it and said they would address it. I was hoping for more updates after that too. The topic isn’t going to go away until it’s resolved. In real world viewing, 4KC still compares favorably to standard 4K IMO, but this technical encoding deficiency has honestly put a damper on 4KC, and the sooner K-scape reclaims the high ground on this the better.



I was shocked to learn you don’t even own a Strato K, but seem compelled to constantly insert yourself in the 4KC discussion. Also, how can you weigh in on a subjective discussion of the Interstellar 4KC without the ability to view 4KC content?



Amen to that!
So I don’t own a K. I’ve seen content on it. Many, many times. Are you going to devolve into some elitist tribalism where you are going to exclude people “because you don’t”…… and my opinion is inferior to anyone else’s? That’s rich.

It doesn’t devalue my stance on people constantly posting on the “issue”when and if there will be some sort of official update on the library. Which I want to see just as much as anyone else. That is mainly why I’m in this thread.

One of my original posts said that I heard from a reliable source it’s being worked on. That didn’t satisfy anyone.

The original thread and hill everyone is dying on is based on something posted that started with the normal library encodes on the V/E, Which they fixed in due time. Did they post on every single encode or fix? No. They responded saying the issue would be addressed. As someone else posted, they had an issue, they reported it, it was fixed. Did they post it? No.

They already responded to the 4KC encoding issue which most are not satisfied with. Yet here we are, devolving into pointing fingers.

I’m asking valid questions. Period. Am I a potential K customer, yes. Will the current encode “issues” stop me from buying a K, probably not.

So, I’ll continue to weigh in as I see fit. It’s my right to do so.
 
Last edited:
The 4KC problem Rmarci identified is a legitimate issue. @tayloe acknowledged it and said they would address it. I was hoping for more updates after that too.....
I feel that some want updates akin to the updates a project manager* would get while others would be happy just to be told "we fixed it."

I know, as a developer, that constant updating was the bane of my existence and didn't seem to accomplish anything. My attitude was always, "unless I say otherwise, I'm still working on it".

* updates like, "we identified the issue, no fix yet". And/or "first fix failed, trying something else." Sort of like the daily huddle for those familiar with the concept.

In some forums, one can make "Post # 1" sticky and the source-of-truth for update information, as opposed to discussions. Can this forum support that?
 
I feel that some want updates akin to the updates a project manager* would get while others would be happy just to be told "we fixed it."

I know, as a developer, that constant updating was the bane of my existence and didn't seem to accomplish anything. My attitude was always, "unless I say otherwise, I'm still working on it".

I don't think anyone cares about status updates short of actual releases. The situation is that, unlike you as a developer, Kscape has not communicated an "unless we say otherwise, we're still working on it" status. For all we know, they've already fixed the problem on new releases -- people are reading tea leaves about average bit rate on new releases, and looking with hope at every re-release with an "upgraded audio/visual quality" note. We could skip all this detective work if they'd just give us an update when they've rolled out the fix to new releases (and ideally some indication of what they intend to do with existing releases).

Seriously, that's it. That's all anyone wants. This forum has a handful of weirdly dedicated trolls who try to stir up drama on every post, but there's nothing dramatic about this request.
 
I don't think anyone cares about status updates short of actual releases. The situation is that, unlike you as a developer, Kscape has not communicated an "unless we say otherwise, we're still working on it" status. For all we know, they've already fixed the problem on new releases -- people are reading tea leaves about average bit rate on new releases, and looking with hope at every re-release with an "upgraded audio/visual quality" note. We could skip all this detective work if they'd just give us an update when they've rolled out the fix to new releases (and ideally some indication of what they intend to do with existing releases).

Seriously, that's it. That's all anyone wants. This forum has a handful of weirdly dedicated trolls who try to stir up drama on every post, but there's nothing dramatic about this request.
I’d suggest the fact the CEO has weighed in on it, which they didn’t before is an indication of where things are at and given some of the legal ramifications of how those captures were obtained I wouldn’t be surprised if everyone else have been advised not to engage in any discussions about it.
 
I don't think anyone cares about status updates short of actual releases. The situation is that, unlike you as a developer, Kscape has not communicated an "unless we say otherwise, we're still working on it" status. For all we know, they've already fixed the problem on new releases -- people are reading tea leaves about average bit rate on new releases, and looking with hope at every re-release with an "upgraded audio/visual quality" note. We could skip all this detective work if they'd just give us an update when they've rolled out the fix to new releases (and ideally some indication of what they intend to do with existing releases).

Seriously, that's it. That's all anyone wants. This forum has a handful of weirdly dedicated trolls who try to stir up drama on every post, but there's nothing dramatic about this request.

Not a big ask IMO. 🤞
 
I was certainly optimistic that they would when I asked my question on 9/21, but... it's been two full weeks and there is no response at all, not even a "we're still working on figuring out timing" or anything. I very much hope you're correct, but I'm starting to fear that their comms strategy here is to let things blow over and not comment again.

Which, to allow myself a little cynicism, is probably an optimal strategy from some perspectives. The thread with the analysis is gone from the internet, so there's no longer any record of the problems, and most people are still acting like 4KC is an unquestionable upgrade, with complaints going back to the "when will this title be upgraded to 4KC?" Why bother saying anything and risk stirring up another hornet's nest, especially if what they'd say is -- as I increasingly suspect -- the unpopular thing that there are no plans to re-encode already-encoded movies.

Unfortunately, that leaves people like me in the lurch. Right now, it's well established that the ideal strategy is to download the superior 4K encodes and to ignore the inferior 4KC ones. I'm willing to believe that this will change at some point in the future, but if Kscape is unwilling to say when it will change or for which movies, and nobody is doing any kind of analysis that could independently demonstrate it... do I just keep downloading the base 4K movies forever, throwing away the whole reason I spent extra for the Strato K over the E? Do I decide that after some point from now (next month? 3 months? 6 months?) I should download new releases in 4KC but still keep 4K for back-catalog stuff that will never get updated? Is there a point at which I should expect the back catalog to be updated?

I genuinely don't know. I just want to use this machine in the best way possible, and for them to give me the information to let me do this, but instead I'm left guessing, because -- I guess? -- they just don't want to talk about it. It's frustrating.
Well but if you keep downloading the base 4k version you don’t have a way of knowing if it is an encode after those issues were fixed or an older one riddled with issues because there is no flag on the store to tell you this or when it was last updated. You can only be relatively certain if it’s a new release title from a certain time frame forward.

So even if they fix the 4KC titles you may not have anyway of knowing if individual titles are fixed or not which is incredible to me that is treated as an acceptable situation, never mind the lack of updates on the 4KC situation.
 
I’d look at Interstellar. I’ve only looked at the HDR (not 4KC) and the SDR. Both have been really disappointing to me. I’m 1/2 tempted to Email K-scape and see if I can open a dialog. Most of my disappointment comes from the lack of format change.

After a little while today, I’m going to fire up my BD copy and compare to K-scape.
Format change as in aspect change? The majority of Nolan titles if not all of them do not change aspect with digital retailers. Only on disc.
 
Format change as in aspect change? The majority of Nolan titles if not all of them do not change aspect with digital retailers. Only on disc.
Thanks, someone pointed that out as all my Nolan films are on disc. That is unfortunate.
 
Back
Top