• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

When should we expect luma improvements in 4K Cinematic?

We have all benefited from Kaleidescape's direct engagement here, so I also hope it continues in a constructive manner. I do also hope to see formal recognition of any final changes or improvements coming out of the recent feedback. I hope to see a strong, positive bookend to the whole situation and so sharing that hope in public and private channels.
 
We have all benefited from Kaleidescape's direct engagement here, so I also hope it continues in a constructive manner. I do also hope to see formal recognition of any final changes or improvements coming out of the recent feedback. I hope to see a strong, positive bookend to the whole situation and so sharing that hope in public and private channels.
Have you recommended that they add a way of knowing what title version/when a title was last updated?
 
You can't retrieve real information that's been lost by cranking up sharpness to emphasize the information that remains. Doing destructive blur/sharpen cycles on an image is not as good as just having a sharp image to begin with.

As to how Kscape will fix the issues... well, my assumption is that they'll fix them by making the encode better, rather than by leaving it bad and turning up a sharpen knob. But all we have from them on this topic are the two posts linked at the top of this thread, so people's guesses will just be calibrated to how cynical the guesser is, and I'd rather not have the thread full of a bunch of random uninformed opinions, as I'm still holding out hope (probably vainly at this point) that @tayloe or some other Kscape person will give us more information.
I know that you can't retrieve information by using sharpness. I never suggested otherwise.

What I was alluding to is that before you seek timescales as to when changes are made you might be better off clarifying what changes you are expecting and what changes K are going to deliver. Otherwise disappointment might arise and it is patently obvious what happens on here when folks are disappointed. All I am suggesting is that effective expectation management might temper some of the responses around here.
 
I know that you can't retrieve information by using sharpness. I never suggested otherwise.

What I was alluding to is that before you seek timescales as to when changes are made you might be better off clarifying what changes you are expecting and what changes K are going to deliver. Otherwise disappointment might arise and it is patently obvious what happens on here when folks are disappointed. All I am suggesting is that effective expectation management might temper some of the responses around here.

The evidence suggests the added chroma led to reduced luma, creating an image softer than reference.

At the most basic level, the ask is to adjust the 4KC encoding recipe to ensure a sharpness that is at least on par with the 4:2:0 encodes and/or is as close to the mezzanine file as possible.
 
The evidence suggests the added chroma led to reduced luma, creating an image softer than reference.

At the most basic level, the ask is to adjust the 4KC encoding recipe to ensure a sharpness that is at least on par with the 4:2:0 encodes and/or is as close to the mezzanine file as possible.
Even that ask is ambiguous. At least on par as in objectively contains the same amount of luma information or subjectively can be perceived to be as sharp? This is why I suggest disappointment can arise.

As far as close to the mezzanine file as possible this is likely to be an unrealistic ask as almost certainly trade offs will need to be made given constraints such as file size, bandwidth, available decoding and encoding capabilities and so forth. Without defining the constraints some folks are bound to be disappointed as there will usually be more left on the table if the constraints were removed or relaxed.

My personal opinion is that K purposely decided to reduce luma resolution to keep the file size and/or bandwidth within a certain range given that based on their subjective evaluation and feedback the loss was at least in their eyes imperceptible or not unacceptably worse. Given those constraints we probably already have something as close to the mezzanine as possible. Yet some folks are disappointed.
 
I do not believe that to be true, and based on the statements they've made, it doesn't seem like they do either. But I would be thrilled for Kscape reps to clarify their position further. If you want to pick fights about the quality of Cinematic, I encourage you to choose a different thread for it.
 
I do not believe that to be true, and based on the statements they've made, it doesn't seem like they do either. But I would be thrilled for Kscape reps to clarify their position further. If you want to pick fights about the quality of Cinematic, I encourage you to choose a different thread for it.
Were you responding to me?
 
Have you recommended that they add a way of knowing what title version/when a title was last updated?
I haven't made that recommendation, but I think it's a neat idea. I always like seeing release notes/patch notes on new software releases, so a versioning history on content is a cool idea.
 
I haven't made that recommendation, but I think it's a neat idea. I always like seeing release notes/patch notes on new software releases, so a versioning history on content is a cool idea.
Agreed. Maybe have another clickable link that shows version info on the miniature.

11/1/26 - improved encoding with updated tools

11/27/26 - improved luma channels.
 
Comparing Mortal Kombat II Dolby vision encode to cinematic encode to disc.
Dolby vision encode is the sharpest, followed by disc, the least sharp is the cinematic, which also takes up the most space. I’m pausing and matching timestamps, not scientific like Rmarci….
In motion… it’s a different story, cinematic is easier on the eyes in faster motion and quick cuts…
Top gun maverick… ready player one… same results. (Rmarci used to say to me no way in motion is better) This should be a easy encode fix.. some ppl on the forum are saying “HDR” is brighter etc on cinematic… this is simply not true on any title I’ve compared. “Oblivion” was mentioned… K has the 1000 Nit digital version which is significantly brighter than the disc… their regular encode and cinematic is brighter then disc due to this reason.
 
@josh holding out hope for your thoughts on this.

The original mega thread that captured this exchange is gone at the request of the OP. Fine.

The thread discussing the mega thread had morphed into to a venue to continue this type of discussion, and seemed to be turning a corner but was then closed at your discretion. So be it.

I’d love your thoughts on the right evergreen venue to continue these transcoding and image improvement discussions and questions for Kscape. Either an existing thread you recommend moving to, or the creation of a new one.

Despite some member departures, there’s clearly still a large appetite for it.
HI... thanks. Are you thinking about a thread like this one: 4K Cinematic: Movie Availability and Release Order but specifically for the luma 'fix'? That would obviously take someone at Kaleidescape agreeing to post these in the forum area. I'd certainly make one if @MikeKobb or @J.Green would add the info on releases.
 
HI... thanks. Are you thinking about a thread like this one: 4K Cinematic: Movie Availability and Release Order but specifically for the luma 'fix'? That would obviously take someone at Kaleidescape agreeing to post these in the forum area. I'd certainly make one if @MikeKobb or @J.Green would add the info on releases.

Thanks for the reply — I’m sure there’s a lot on your plate.

Thread purpose: not specifically for luma — but a thread more broadly to facilitate questions and updates about transcoding / encoding recipe changes, updates, timelines for fixes. Members could flag anomalies etc.

I’m open to either option. @MikeKobb would this discussion fit in the existing thread Josh mentioned or is it specific enough to warrant its own thread? And is it a topic you and your team would be willing to engage in? Thanks for your consideration.
 
I noticed this morning that the first two LOTR movies are showing up at the top of the new 4K cinematic section on the store again. They were some of the earliest encodes. Does that mean they’ve seen improvements? I didn’t have them downloaded before, so can’t see the update notes.
 
I noticed this morning that the first two LOTR movies are showing up at the top of the new 4K cinematic section on the store again. They were some of the earliest encodes. Does that mean they’ve seen improvements? I didn’t have them downloaded before, so can’t see the update notes.
I only have the "Extended" versions downloaded to my system and none of them have triggered any update status AFAIK. Hopefully someone can chip in on the "Theatrical" versions - which continues to exclude "The Return of the King" from the Cinematic versions 🤷‍♀️

Out of curiosity what filters do you have set to see "new 4K Cinematic" section.
 
I only have the "Extended" versions downloaded to my system and none of them have triggered any update status AFAIK. Hopefully someone can chip in on the "Theatrical" versions - which continues to exclude "The Return of the King" from the Cinematic versions 🤷‍♀️

Out of curiosity what filters do you have set to see "new 4K Cinematic" section.
Don’t have any filters set, was just looking at the content row in the app, and they showed at the front again, which usually means something was changed, as the latest stuff is at the front, but maybe not in this case.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0627.png
    IMG_0627.png
    2.5 MB · Views: 7
Don’t have any filters set, was just looking at the content row in the app, and they showed at the front again, which usually means something was changed, as the latest stuff is at the front, but maybe not in this case.
Got it - I rarely use the app, so my experiences are with the web-ui. Strange that the Extended versions of those 2 titles also appear in that listing, yet I haven't received any update notificiations - @MikeKobb, any input you can offer?
 
Got it - I rarely use the app, so my experiences are with the web-ui. Strange that the Extended versions of those 2 titles also appear in that listing, yet I haven't received any update notificiations - @MikeKobb, any input you can offer?
On the web it was showing me that a "new digital to disc offer" or something like that, was available, indicating something had changed.
 
Now you see the value Rmarci added… he would have already posted the digital stream encode vs disc encode vs K encode… on almost every new title… and checked if a title was indeed updated…
It’s a damn shame!!!! A absolute disaster to have lost or had that asset silenced
 
Back
Top