• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

OLED vs Projector opinions

HiFiHippie

Well-known member
⭐️⭐️PATRON⭐️⭐️
Joined
Sep 1, 2025
Messages
299
Location
Florida
So it’s time for me to update my system in our dedicated media room. I currently have a projection based system comprising of a JVC RS 500 bulb based projector with a Da Lite 100 inch screen. My initial plan was to upgrade was to upgrade to a JVC NZ 800/900 laser projector and upgrade the screen to a Stewart Studiotek G4 white screen. I cannot upgrade the screen size due to the size of my room and the speaker placement that I’m using.

So my question is due to the limited size of the screen I use, should I be looking at panel tv option instead of upgrading my projector. One option is a LG 97 inch OLED G6 which should be released mid to late March early April timeframe. My media room has a flat black ceiling with dark gray walls.

My components consist of: Kscape Strato C( I would consider the upgrade to the V for Dolby Vision for OLED), Panasonic 9000 4k player for physical media, Apple TV 4K, Lumagen Radiance Pro and a Xbox X console. I also have a Oppo 4k player which I only use for multi channel sacd playback.

I feel the difference in screen from the OLED to Projector is minimal. The OLED should be brighter in nits for hdr the the projector? The thing I will miss the most from the projector is viewing the 3d content.

Any thoughts or opinions would be much appreciated

Richard
 
My first instinct was that, as much as love my projector, with your being limited to a 100" screen, some of the appeal and benefit of a projector does diminish a bit. My next thought was to estimate how much brightness you would have with an NZ900 (which I have), with a 100" ST130-G4, and the calculator came up with around 350 nits (depending on the throw distance).

That's a huge amount of brightness for a projector, and with the JVC's native contrast, along with being able to close down the iris to further enhance black levels, that would be a pretty spectacular image. You wouldn't have OLED blacks, but they would be quite good.

I guess part of it comes down to your feelings about watching a reflected image with the projector, vs an emissive image from the OLED. Some people have strong preferences in this regard, and this could lean you one way or the other.

I have a 166" 2.40:1 screen in my theater, and recently got a 77" Samsung S95F OLED for my family room. The OLED's picture quality is definitely better, although the NZ900's is quite good as well, and gives it a good run for the money. With the size difference in my case, any 'serious' movie watching is in the theater. More casual watching of Netflix shows and such is with the OLED. Your situation is different which makes the decision harder.

Both are good choices; hard to know which would better suit you.
 
I have a 97" LG M3 and it's pretty great. If getting a panel that large into the space isn't an issue, I don't see how you go with a projector unless 3D is that important to you.
 
If you are limited to 100” and a 97”LG OLED is an option, then there’s no question: OLED. You could buy an NZ900, narrow it down to 100” with all its brightness, add your Lumagen processor and the OLED would still be brighter, clearer, sharper, with better colors, HDR, and overall image. Gaming? Sports? Low latency? VRR? You could throw anything at it, No projector overhead with associated noise, potentially simpler cable layout, reduced or eliminated light pollution, and more.

There’s only one thing that shifts the weight towards the projector, and you already mentioned it: 3D. So, how important is that for you? Is your 3D solo or social? If you mostly watch 3D alone, I’d sell the Lumagen (which you won’t need with the OLED) and buy an Apple Vision Pro. Do the necessary setup to send audio to your theater, and let the headset be your new 3D screen. With the LG OLED for 2D viewing and AVP’s OLEDs for 3D (and no longer limited to 100”) you’ll have very consistent video experiences with the best of both worlds.
 
If you can squeeze another 5" into the space, I'd consider waiting for Sony's 115" Micro RGB panel, or Samsung's version that's available now, assuming your budget allows. Retail is $30K (Sony's should be similar if not the same in cost).

Jim
 
A couple things to consider for both choices:

If you haven’t seen how 24Hz motion looks on an OLED I suggest you try to get a demo. It can be a quite jarring without any kind of motion smoothing.

I would be concerned about putting a light cannon like an NZ800/NZ900 in that room without having something like black velvet on the walls and ceiling. You will get some help if you are using the Studiotek 130 G4 material when it comes to focusing light back at the MVP but there will still be a significant amount of reflected light bouncing around that room.
 
At 100" its a tough call. Personally there is something...very subjective I know that makes a projection system "feel" more cinematic than a flat panel.,,,even thou I know on a technical level the flat panel is far superior.

In my case ...at 135" screen size projection is the only viable choice. Even if there were a viable 135 inch flat panel of some sort...I would need to remove my roof and airlift the thing in =P.

If video walls ever reach reasonable prices I can see that being something I change to.
 
A couple things to consider for both choices:

If you haven’t seen how 24Hz motion looks on an OLED I suggest you try to get a demo. It can be a quite jarring without any kind of motion smoothing.

I would be concerned about putting a light cannon like an NZ800/NZ900 in that room without having something like black velvet on the walls and ceiling. You will get some help if you are using the Studiotek 130 G4 material when it comes to focusing light back at the MVP but there will still be a significant amount of reflected light bouncing around that room.
I 2nd this! One of the best things I ever did in my dedicated room is cover every wall and ceiling in black velvet...cover every LED light on equipment, etc. Even in the middle of the afternoon...with no equipment on in the room I cannot see my hand in front of my face. During movie watching...the screen almost looks like its floating in space.
 
Never heard anybody call a 3000lumen projector a "light canon" before. ;)
But yes, for every projection, the room should be as dark as possible - and yes, the brighter the projection gets, the more important it is.
If you go towards displays, you don´t need this to preserve contrast, but I still recommend doing it to enhance the immersion. The lesser you see of the room, the more convincing it is you are in the movie and not a room.
Having said this, have a close look at the full black or near black content. This can be quite revealing, as displays are usually not designed for performing in a blackenend out environment. Hence, you might see artefacts you don´t see in daylight or even ambient light conditions you will most likely have in conventional showrooms.
 
If you can squeeze another 5" into the space, I'd consider waiting for Sony's 115" Micro RGB panel, or Samsung's version that's available now, assuming your budget allows. Retail is $30K (Sony's should be similar if not the same in cost).

Jim
If I tell my wife the TV will cost $30K, she may say, "Let's stop watching TV". LOL
 
Never heard anybody call a 3000lumen projector a "light canon" before. ;)
I think it certainly fits the term when used with a 100” Studiotek 130 in a room size that cannot accomadate a larger screen.

I have flat dark gray paint on my walls and ceiling and I get a distracting amount of light being reflected from my .7 gain woven screen with around 100 nits of brightness.
 
I really think overall people have not considered the logistics of super large flat panels TVs...rapidly reaching the point where they simply will not fit thru most house doors. Not too mention delivery methods and cost. That said, I am sure Best Buy will still have to deal with idiots somehow expecting to pickup a 88 OLED in their Teslas.
 
I think it certainly fits the term when used with a 100” Studiotek 130 in a room size that cannot accomadate a larger screen.
The gain and size of the screen doesn´t affect the light output of a projector, it only changes the brightness of the image on screen.
3000 lumen is for sure at the higher end of the standard low brightness consumer projectors, it´s just that I wouldn´t call it a "light canon". That´s all. 🍻
 
I really think overall people have not considered the logistics of super large flat panels TVs...rapidly reaching the point where they simply will not fit thru most house doors. Not too mention delivery methods and cost. That said, I am sure Best Buy will still have to deal with idiots somehow expecting to pickup a 88 OLED in their Teslas.

The size shouldn't be a problem, but I agree there are some logistical concerns. For me it was a weight issue. About 15 years ago I purchased a Panasonic 152" plasma TV (152UX1) to use in a theater at one of my other homes. The size wasn't the problem, it fit through all the doors, it was the weight that presented challenges, both in movement and in wall mounting. We had to completely rebuild the wall using a combination of 4X4, 4x6 beams, and steel straps. It took 6 very strong guys to move and hang it using a special mount designed by Panasonic. It weighed about 1200 pounds if I remember correctly. I think the new 115" Micro RGB panels are in the 200 pound range, nothing like the old Plasma displays!

Jim
 
I actually mocked out a 115” panel with cardboard and found it impossible to maneuver up my staircase that has a turn in it. I would definitely suggest a dry run if you have any concern at all about moving it into your space.
 
I agree, if going upstairs/downstairs you can find some difficult angles depending on the house design. Tight hallways can be a problem as well. I should have qualified my above comment to note those potential issues. It was smart to do a cardboard cutout, as long as you also account for the thickness difference between cardboard and the display in very tight areas.

Jim
 
After years of having various projectors with screens ranging from 106-120 inches I can say you will be very happy with a flat panel. after my latest move and due to the attic ceiling limitations i went with a 100inch Hisense miniLed. I have had a 75inch sony OLED in my family room for 4 years and I do love the picture. But now the TV has noticeable Burn in from one of the news channels being on throughout the day. so definitely be wary of Burn in with OLED's. going back and forth between my OLED and LED tv I can honestly say the gap in black levels has been narrowed significantly. and my newer 100inch LED has been measured at 1500 Nits and is noticeably brighter than the OLED. Being able to watch sports and regular TV with the lights on is an advantage. And when you go totally dark for movie nights the HDR hi-lights will really blow you away.
 
I have a 97" LG M3 and it's pretty great. If getting a panel that large into the space isn't an issue, I don't see how you go with a projector unless 3D is that important to you.
Getting the panel into the room won’t be an issue. As for the 3d viewing I have really enjoyed it over the years but I am the only one who typically is watching it. And the physical media releases are getting less every year, and the cost of importing them from Japan continue to go up.
 
If you are limited to 100” and a 97”LG OLED is an option, then there’s no question: OLED. You could buy an NZ900, narrow it down to 100” with all its brightness, add your Lumagen processor and the OLED would still be brighter, clearer, sharper, with better colors, HDR, and overall image. Gaming? Sports? Low latency? VRR? You could throw anything at it, No projector overhead with associated noise, potentially simpler cable layout, reduced or eliminated light pollution, and more.

There’s only one thing that shifts the weight towards the projector, and you already mentioned it: 3D. So, how important is that for you? Is your 3D solo or social? If you mostly watch 3D alone, I’d sell the Lumagen (which you won’t need with the OLED) and buy an Apple Vision Pro. Do the necessary setup to send audio to your theater, and let the headset be your new 3D screen. With the LG OLED for 2D viewing and AVP’s OLEDs for 3D (and no longer limited to 100”) you’ll have very consistent video experiences with the best of both worlds.
Your post makes a lot of sense to me, I think not being able to watch 3d content won’t be an issue over time. I actually have a Lumagen Artisan that is on preorder to go with my new projector I was going to upgrade. Do you feel that the Artisan would not be needed with OLED panel tv?
 
Back
Top