• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

Evil Dead Burn no 4KC... what is the decision making process?

Add me to the list of owners who believe new titles, especially from major studios, should be given the Cinematic treatment. No one expects every catalogue title to be converted immediately, but there should be some expectation that most if not all will be.

As to Horror titles. K has not really done much to encourage purchases.

A Nightmare On Elm Street movies were asked for repeatedly here but are sadly still HD only.
We get Attack From Mars (Tim Burton) in 4k but Sweeney Todd, Tim Burton also, still HD only.
Friday The 13th Part 2 - Great 4k available. Still HD.
 
The purported data-driven analysis is a self-fulfilling prophecy at this point. As the user base changes by lowering the cost of entry the existing purchasing trends become worthless. We need a more structured approach than horror hasn't done well traditionally so we don't try.
 
One thing with horror is that it's a genre that's very well served by boutique disc labels, with catalog that Kscape will just never have (same as foreign/arthouse stuff). So anyone who's into those genres needs to be big into disc stuff anyway, and that probably means that they punch under their weight on Kscape relative to their popularity among movie-watchers in general.
 
While I agree, it is puzzling that K doesn't at least make their best effort with what they do carry. I started this thread because I was concerned that Evil Dead Burn didn't get a 4KC release. Yes, it is available in 4K, but at $40 for a premium release (thanks Warner Bros) it really should have received premium treatment. I don't generally have a lot of patience, but I refuse to pick it up at that price when I can wait for the physical release and get basically the same quality for the same price or less (and have a copy I physically own). To me, that is simply K operating in their status quo of people don't generally buy it on our platform so we aren't going to offer it in our new premium format. Maybe people don't want to pay a premium for a non-premium product. I would have picked it up day one if it had been 4KC. The thought that it is coming out on BD in the future shouldn't absolve K from providing a top-tier product. In fact, it should be the exact opposite.
 
I would add to your reasoning. K offers movies that are still running in theaters. If a studio like WB is going to charge the price they do, while the movie is still in theaters, give me something as close to the theatrical experience as possible.
 
I really do agree with this. When positioning yourselves as the premier movie player, there shouldn't be any picking and choosing which content gets the premier treatment, because that makes the users have to pick and choose on their end. Eliminate questions, eliminate doubts, provide the highest quality for every single title and actually back up the marketing claims.
I agree. I’m awaiting a strato k end of September. My first venture into Kaleidescape. And I have become a bit disillusioned now I’m tracking the store actively.
So much so I created a spreadsheet of all the 4k discs I own to see how the Kaleidescape equivalents are online, and it’s actually a bit depressing. And that is a mix of video 4k vs KS only having HD. But also audio. So many missing atmos when it is available.
The 4KC was what made me bite the bullet. I can stop buying new releases with this new standard. And then, it actually isn’t fully embraced. So confusing. Seems to be only for the ‘cliche’ blockbusters.
 
Please don’t be discouraged. Kaleidescape offers a wonderful unique experience.
If you have the Blu-ray Discs that often came with the 4K disks you can do the disk to digital option.
Be assured that in most cases the sound quality, although not always Atmos is still amazing as you will experience.
With your Strato K using Cinematic files will be better than anything you have experienced before in video. You will be surprised at how many movies, concerts etc that you will acquire over time.
Also the convenience of the system and watching the different curated and your own scenes is on option not available on any other platform.
 
I’m really confused though. If it’s going by popularity with these 4K Cinematic titles why in the world are we seeing The Parent Trap, The Bad Guys 2, The Drop before we’re seeing more popular titles? There’s no way those are more popular than Goodfellas, Godfather, all the Transformers, Tron and so on.
 
Yeah, something doesn’t add up here... Passenger 2026 is a horror movie that did twice as poorly at the box office, yet it got the Cinematic treatment. Evil Dead is a pretty big franchise and deserved the same treatment.
Correct, both Evil Dead Burn and Evil Dead Rise are more popular than Passenger based upon K's algorithm. The two films, released in recent years, should be considered "modern" horror films and not the catalog horror titles that K likes to malign. I'll have plenty more to say on that topic as we enter the Halloween season, but for now the point is: These titles should receive 4KC upgrades. (And, honestly, I expect them to. I think @MikeKobb may have seen "Evil Dead" and reacted.)
 
Honest answer here: Passenger is a somewhat of an outlier as it was in a group of first titles available for testing 4K Cinematic.

To state again, we are prioritizing processing on titles that are the most purchased and watched by our customers. (This is distinct from box office performance, although obviously many movies that do well at the box office also do well with our customers.)

We understand that there will be titles - in horror and otherwise - where customers who are fans will want the 4K Cinematic treatment but the overall popularity among our customers doesn't justify that investment. We do monitor sales performance. If a movie performs better than anticipated, we will revisit and produce 4K Cinematic versions as well.
 
To state again, we are prioritizing processing on titles that are the most purchased and watched by our customers. (This is distinct from box office performance, although obviously many movies that do well at the box office also do well with our customers.)

Is this a comment about back-catalog, or does it also apply to new releases -- i.e. will there be movies where you have the mezzanines available to create 4K Cinematic, but won't bother?
 
Is this a comment about back-catalog, or does it also apply to new releases -- i.e. will there be movies where you have the mezzanines available to create 4K Cinematic, but won't bother?
That's right. 4K Cinematic is derived from the same mezzanine files that are used to produce the other variants. But as stated above, there is still an investment required to produce each version -- CPU time, storage, QA/QC time, etc. So to justify producing the additional three variants of the film, it needs to be one that will sell well enough to warrant that investment. As disappointing as I know it is to anyone whose desired title is not available, this is what's necessary to have a sustainable business. As the size of our user base grows, it will be increasingly easy to hit that bar.
 
We understand that there will be titles - in horror and otherwise - where customers who are fans will want the 4K Cinematic treatment but the overall popularity among our customers doesn't justify that investment. We do monitor sales performance. If a movie performs better than anticipated, we will revisit and produce 4K Cinematic versions as well.
To be honest. I don’t think it has anything to do with horror. It’s that as customers, we don’t understand why all new releases don’t get the 4k cinematic version.
If the sales pitch was “oh, by the way, we are going to pick and choose what new releases we think deserve the 4kC treatment based on data”, I wouldn’t have bought the K.
 
That's right. 4K Cinematic is derived from the same mezzanine files that are used to produce the other variants. But as stated above, there is still an investment required to produce each version -- CPU time, storage, QA/QC time, etc. So to justify producing the additional three variants of the film, it needs to be one that will sell well enough to warrant that investment. As disappointing as I know it is to anyone whose desired title is not available, this is what's necessary to have a sustainable business. As the size of our user base grows, it will be increasingly easy to hit that bar.

Oof. I was hoping people were misunderstanding and getting disappointed for nothing, but that's genuinely disappointing. When the whole selling point of your extremely expensive device is that it's higher-quality than disc, a little asterisk saying "as long as you like the biggest blockbusters and not anything more niche or interesting" is an ugly asterisk.

I think everyone understands that converting the whole back catalog is a big task that needs prioritization. I don't think anyone not employed by Kaleidescape understands the idea that you're going to choose not to deliver new movies in the best possible quality.
 
As the size of our user base grows, it will be increasingly easy to hit that bar.
That's one way to look at it. The other way would be if you hit that bar, the size of your user base will grow faster. Eliminate the questions and variability and just be the ultimate experience.
 
That's right. 4K Cinematic is derived from the same mezzanine files that are used to produce the other variants. But as stated above, there is still an investment required to produce each version -- CPU time, storage, QA/QC time, etc. So to justify producing the additional three variants of the film, it needs to be one that will sell well enough to warrant that investment. As disappointing as I know it is to anyone whose desired title is not available, this is what's necessary to have a sustainable business. As the size of our user base grows, it will be increasingly easy to hit that bar.
This is a bad policy decision. The customer-focused and quality-centric approach is that all 4K titles get 4KC. Very simple. Otherwise, it seems like K-scape is backpedaling on their own program. If K-scape is resource constrained with insufficient server capacity or manpower, that needs to be addressed in a way that doesn’t shortchange the customers and K’s reputation of offering the best quality possible.
 
Back
Top