• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

Thoughts as a new Kaleidescape User

Got mine today, got it set up, and watched a movie. My first day thoughts:

1. The setup is terrible, just an incredibly chaotic experience. You do a little on the device, then you need to do your account setup on an app; after that, major functionality (the store, or even the "setup videos" in the settings menu) won't work until invisible background processes whose progress you can't track complete; once the store is downloaded, you can't buy anything until you set a PIN, which you can't do on the device or the app -- you need to type in a URL and oh btw that won't work on the phone where you installed the app (because the URL just directs into the app, which doesn't have the functionality), so you need to have a desktop browser in addition to the device and your phone; and then basic functionality like HDMI-CEC is completely undocumented behind settings on the web site. I'd say it's shocking how bad the out-of-box experience is... but I remember someone (here or on AVS) posting that the setup is obviously meant to be completed by your installer before you ever see it, and, yep, that's exactly what this is. I suspect they view the settings not being visible on the box as a feature, even.

2. The blue front panel lights look really cheap, but thankfully can be turned off. The device is otherwise unobtrusive physically, except that at one point -- I'm not sure if it's because I was downloading, or because it was still doing some background setup, or both -- the fans came on full speed, and they were very loud. I didn't hear them again at any point, so hopefully that was a fluke, because when they're going all out, they're louder than any other device I have -- game consoles, desktop PCs, laptops, whatever.

3. Downloads were slower than I expected. I had read a lot of "ten minutes" talk, but downloading Project Hail Mary in 4KC took 25 minutes. It's a 2.5Gb/s network with 1.2Gb/s internet (and I routinely get full speed when downloading from e.g. Steam), so the device itself, or the Kscape servers, is the bottleneck here. I'm not sure if this is normal speed and this is a big movie, if the servers were unusually slow (I could believe that Friday evenings hammer the servers hard), or if there's some kind of esoteric network config that's not set up right and I'm not getting full speed. If it's the latter, not sure I have any way to test, tbh.

4. The overall vibe of using this device felt a lot more like using a disc player than a modern streaming device like an Apple TV -- the UI is kinda dated and clunky (if inoffensive); the remote is basically fine, but is old-style IR that you need to have line-of-sight with (and I know this is another custom installer thing and you're supposed to have some Crestron whatever). But realistically, a small company can't compete with Apple on UI or performance -- and compared to a Panasonic UHD-BD player, it's very responsive and has a modern UI. Since that's my other real option, it's a meaningful comparison.

5. My intention in buying this was for it to sit alongside my discs, not to replace them: anything I really care about and want to rewatch, I get on disc so I actually own it, and then this gets used for movies that I'll want to watch once and probably never again, so it's mostly just rentals. Of course, within an hour, I went soft on that, as 28 Weeks Later was on sale for $2.50 more than the rental, and why not pay that extra $2.50 even if I probably will never watch it a second time. We'll see how my usage evolves over time. As much as I hate DRMed stuff in principle -- you don't really own DRMed stuff and it invariably disappears in the long run -- I have to admit that there's a rather less "long run" left for me than there was a quarter century ago when I was ripping my DRM-free CDs to FLAC, so maybe I should worry less about this.

6. But of course, all the rest of the experience is just a wrapper around the important aspect, which is actually watching the movie. And here, I have no complaints at all. I appreciate the people who do careful pixel-peeping comparisons and collect data on bitrates and chroma resolution and all that, because I'm enough of a tech nerd to love that stuff for its own sake; but when it comes down to actually watching something, I'm way too lazy to ever do that kind of A/B comparison -- one of the reasons I want to just have the best version of a thing is so that I can watch the movie without ever thinking about the technicalities, and this absolutely gave me that. Great Atmos sound, great DV picture, no notes. As for the in-movie experience, it again feels very disc-like in a good way -- streamers always feel like the controls are one step removed from the actual movie, because when you press a button, you can feel everything buffering; here, it just responds, as smoothly as a disc player does. But the in-movie menus are better than disc, and there's no disc whirring away anywhere.

7. My overall takeaway at this point is still that if you had to choose between disc and Kscape, you should choose disc -- it's way cheaper, and there's soooo much more selection on disc, even now; I can't imagine any serious cinephile not having a disc player -- but once you've got a disc player, if you're not going to be bothered by the expenditure, this is a worthwhile addition.
 
Got mine today, got it set up, and watched a movie. My first day thoughts:

1. The setup is terrible, just an incredibly chaotic experience. You do a little on the device, then you need to do your account setup on an app; after that, major functionality (the store, or even the "setup videos" in the settings menu) won't work until invisible background processes whose progress you can't track complete; once the store is downloaded, you can't buy anything until you set a PIN, which you can't do on the device or the app -- you need to type in a URL and oh btw that won't work on the phone where you installed the app (because the URL just directs into the app, which doesn't have the functionality), so you need to have a desktop browser in addition to the device and your phone; and then basic functionality like HDMI-CEC is completely undocumented behind settings on the web site. I'd say it's shocking how bad the out-of-box experience is... but I remember someone (here or on AVS) posting that the setup is obviously meant to be completed by your installer before you ever see it, and, yep, that's exactly what this is. I suspect they view the settings not being visible on the box as a feature, even.

2. The blue front panel lights look really cheap, but thankfully can be turned off. The device is otherwise unobtrusive physically, except that at one point -- I'm not sure if it's because I was downloading, or because it was still doing some background setup, or both -- the fans came on full speed, and they were very loud. I didn't hear them again at any point, so hopefully that was a fluke, because when they're going all out, they're louder than any other device I have -- game consoles, desktop PCs, laptops, whatever.

3. Downloads were slower than I expected. I had read a lot of "ten minutes" talk, but downloading Project Hail Mary in 4KC took 25 minutes. It's a 2.5Gb/s network with 1.2Gb/s internet (and I routinely get full speed when downloading from e.g. Steam), so the device itself, or the Kscape servers, is the bottleneck here. I'm not sure if this is normal speed and this is a big movie, if the servers were unusually slow (I could believe that Friday evenings hammer the servers hard), or if there's some kind of esoteric network config that's not set up right and I'm not getting full speed. If it's the latter, not sure I have any way to test, tbh.

4. The overall vibe of using this device felt a lot more like using a disc player than a modern streaming device like an Apple TV -- the UI is kinda dated and clunky (if inoffensive); the remote is basically fine, but is old-style IR that you need to have line-of-sight with (and I know this is another custom installer thing and you're supposed to have some Crestron whatever). But realistically, a small company can't compete with Apple on UI or performance -- and compared to a Panasonic UHD-BD player, it's very responsive and has a modern UI. Since that's my other real option, it's a meaningful comparison.

5. My intention in buying this was for it to sit alongside my discs, not to replace them: anything I really care about and want to rewatch, I get on disc so I actually own it, and then this gets used for movies that I'll want to watch once and probably never again, so it's mostly just rentals. Of course, within an hour, I went soft on that, as 28 Weeks Later was on sale for $2.50 more than the rental, and why not pay that extra $2.50 even if I probably will never watch it a second time. We'll see how my usage evolves over time. As much as I hate DRMed stuff in principle -- you don't really own DRMed stuff and it invariably disappears in the long run -- I have to admit that there's a rather less "long run" left for me than there was a quarter century ago when I was ripping my DRM-free CDs to FLAC, so maybe I should worry less about this.

6. But of course, all the rest of the experience is just a wrapper around the important aspect, which is actually watching the movie. And here, I have no complaints at all. I appreciate the people who do careful pixel-peeping comparisons and collect data on bitrates and chroma resolution and all that, because I'm enough of a tech nerd to love that stuff for its own sake; but when it comes down to actually watching something, I'm way too lazy to ever do that kind of A/B comparison -- one of the reasons I want to just have the best version of a thing is so that I can watch the movie without ever thinking about the technicalities, and this absolutely gave me that. Great Atmos sound, great DV picture, no notes. As for the in-movie experience, it again feels very disc-like in a good way -- streamers always feel like the controls are one step removed from the actual movie, because when you press a button, you can feel everything buffering; here, it just responds, as smoothly as a disc player does. But the in-movie menus are better than disc, and there's no disc whirring away anywhere.

7. My overall takeaway at this point is still that if you had to choose between disc and Kscape, you should choose disc -- it's way cheaper, and there's soooo much more selection on disc, even now; I can't imagine any serious cinephile not having a disc player -- but once you've got a disc player, if you're not going to be bothered by the expenditure, this is a worthwhile addition.

New K-Scape user myself. 48 hours in now? But I'll say that my experience was opposite. I already had the app setup and an account created when I committed to finding a player. Once I had the player (I bought 2nd hand) I had to manually reset, then it was off the races. Figuring out the app for remote was a smidge frustrating but not bad. The physical remote is quite good, imho.

I'm on Starlink and my internet caps out around 200Mbs. Movies still download in about 45 mins for regular 4K files. Just because you have 1.2Gbs Internet doens't mean you'll get it.

I jumped into a V and am very happy with my purchase. I still need to do a 4K to 4K BD comparison but I'm not sure I'll buy a movie at full price if I have it on 4K BD.

I've only got a dozen or so movies so far and I have the digital offers for the DVD's I've scanned in. I'm waiting on another reader so I can scan in the rest of my BD's. I've been buying physical for about 30 years now. I do not have the collection many of you have but I'm also selective on what I buy. I only buy stuff that I'm going to watch multiple times.

Anyway, the last part of my story is, I had no idea about Kaleidescape. I went to buy a 4K TV on the cheap for my toy room (yes, literally toys) and I was looking at TV's at Sam's club and someone came over to help me. Turned out to be the store manager and we started sharing stories about hobbies. He then clued me in on K-Scape but I thought it was to much and the losing of the "rights" to the stuff you purchase still scares me a little. I started looking at 2nd hand equipment and found a great deal on a V and I'm sure I'll be committing to a server in the not to distant future.

There is a good possibility that store manager is in here....... lol.

-JD-
 
I'm on Starlink and my internet caps out around 200Mbs. Movies still download in about 45 mins for regular 4K files. Just because you have 1.2Gbs Internet doens't mean you'll get it.

I actually looked it up later, and Project Hail Mary in 4KC is 143GB. 25 minutes puts that at about 760Mbps. Another movie later was about 680Mbps. I don't love Comcast, but I'm confident this isn't my internet connectivity -- Steam downloads reliably hit 1.2Gbps on my PC, and even the Steam Machine (which has a slow 1Gbps Ethernet connection like the Strato K) gets 930Mbps on the same switch as the Strato.
 
I actually looked it up later, and Project Hail Mary in 4KC is 143GB. 25 minutes puts that at about 760Mbps. Another movie later was about 680Mbps. I don't love Comcast, but I'm confident this isn't my internet connectivity -- Steam downloads reliably hit 1.2Gbps on my PC, and even the Steam Machine (which has a slow 1Gbps Ethernet connection like the Strato K) gets 930Mbps on the same switch as the Strato.
If I'm not mistaken, Steam is P2P, so you may be right that there is some sort of limitation to the K Server. I'm not downloading 4KC just lowly 4K SDR. I don't get hung up on time to download. It'll get there when it gets there.
 
Welcome aboard! You will love it. I recently added a 72TB Terra to my full 48TB. You can always offload movies to make room like I had been doing for the past year. However, when you sit down to watch a movie and your spouse picks one from the KScape screen and you realize it is one you offloaded it starts to change your mind on how much you want instant access.

Make full use of D2D and as others have said just wait on a sale if D2D prices are high. The relatively recent addition of $4.99 prices for some older catalog titles has been great too. Some get the $4.99 price for a reason but I’ve found some gems in there. I put myself on a monthly budget so I’m more selective and don’t go crazy. Sometimes I’ll buy recent releases just after the theatrical release but I usually wait on the first or 2nd pride drop ($34.99 to 29.99 or 24.99) unless it’s a prime movie we didn’t watch in a theater.
 
Welcome aboard! You will love it. I recently added a 72TB Terra to my full 48TB. You can always offload movies to make room like I had been doing for the past year. However, when you sit down to watch a movie and your spouse picks one from the KScape screen and you realize it is one you offloaded it starts to change your mind on how much you want instant access.

Make full use of D2D and as others have said just wait on a sale if D2D prices are high. The relatively recent addition of $4.99 prices for some older catalog titles has been great too. Some get the $4.99 price for a reason but I’ve found some gems in there. I put myself on a monthly budget so I’m more selective and don’t go crazy. Sometimes I’ll buy recent releases just after the theatrical release but I usually wait on the first or 2nd pride drop ($34.99 to 29.99 or 24.99) unless it’s a prime movie we didn’t watch in a theater.
I've not seen any $4.99 movies as of yet. I scanned in all my DVD's and I'm waiting for a drive to come in to scan my BD's and 4K BD's.

Thanks!
 
I've not seen any $4.99 movies as of yet. I scanned in all my DVD's and I'm waiting for a drive to come in to scan my BD's and 4K BD's.

Thanks!
Go to the Movies on Sale thread on this forum. Ironcross posts all the decreases and increases in content prices as sales come and go. If you scroll those you’ll see several on sale for $4.99. This is a fairly big deal because the first 4+ years of my K experience saw $9.99 as the low sale price on any movie. There are many D2D offers for 3.14 for HD, 4.50 or 4.92 to 4K. Then you see some for up to 13.xx, 17.xx and 21.xx. Those are usually the ones you’ll flag and buy when sale price is lower than the D2D price. The only way to see D2D prices is to catalog your collection. You can scan your Blu-ray Discs but not your 4K. Even if the drive will physically scan the 4K and Kaleidescape accepts it you will not get extra D2D credit beyond owning the HD Blu-ray. Since almost all 4K physical media comes with a Blu-ray version that hasn’t been an issue, but it is unfortunate that we can’t get better pricing if we already own a 4K disc.
 
Last edited:
Go to the Movies on Sale thread on this forum. Ironcross posts all the decreases and increases in content prices as sales come and go. If you scroll those you’ll see several on sale for $4.99. This is a fairly big deal because the first 4+ years of my K experience saw $9.99 as the low sale price on any movie. There are many D2D offers for 3.14 for HD, 4.50 or 4.92 to 4K. Then you see some for up to 13.xx, 17.xx and 21.xx. Those are usually the ones you’ll flag and buy when sale price is lower than the D2D price. The only way to see D2D prices is to catalog your collection. You can scan your Blu-ray Discs but not your 4K. Even if the drive will physically scan the 4K and Kaleidescape accepts it you will not get extra D2D credit beyond owning the HD Blu-ray. Since almost all 4K physical media comes with a Blu-ray version that hasn’t been an issue, but it is unfortunate that we can’t get better pricing if we already own a 4K disc.
I’m not seeing that thread.

*Edit* Found it. Separate subforum.
 
Go to the Movies on Sale thread on this forum. Ironcross posts all the decreases and increases in content prices as sales come and go. If you scroll those you’ll see several on sale for $4.99. This is a fairly big deal because the first 4+ years of my K experience saw $9.99 as the low sale price on any movie. There are many D2D offers for 3.14 for HD, 4.50 or 4.92 to 4K. Then you see some for up to 13.xx, 17.xx and 21.xx. Those are usually the ones you’ll flag and buy when sale price is lower than the D2D price. The only way to see D2D prices is to catalog your collection. You can scan your Blu-ray Discs but not your 4K. Even if the drive will physically scan the 4K and Kaleidescape accepts it you will not get extra D2D credit beyond owning the HD Blu-ray. Since almost all 4K physical media comes with a Blu-ray version that hasn’t been an issue, but it is unfortunate that we can’t get better pricing if we already own a 4K disc.
I had several 4K discs that didn't come with a Blu-ray. I scanned them all without a problem. True, you don't get any additional D2D creadit, but I still bought a few because I prefer Kscape and now I can get 4K C for some of them.
 
I got into K this year, got a V but immediately upgraded to the K. I love the quality and I was very surprised by how good HD looked as well (the PJ setup is good but I was still very surprised). It would be nice to see more HD titles upgraded to 4K/Cinematic, as there are a lot of movies that I want to own that are still only in HD.
 
I got into K this year, got a V but immediately upgraded to the K. I love the quality and I was very surprised by how good HD looked as well

When I first saw HD-only movies on the store, I was appalled; but then I remembered that this actually means Blu-ray quality, and oh yeah, I watch tons of Blu-rays and they can look great for movies that don't need HDR or a wide DCI-P3 gamut.
 
When I first saw HD-only movies on the store, I was appalled; but then I remembered that this actually means Blu-ray quality, and oh yeah, I watch tons of Blu-rays and they can look great for movies that don't need HDR or a wide DCI-P3 gamut.
Exactly the thought I had when I saw HD titles listed. They are not necessarily to be avoided! I’d still like them upgraded though… :ROFLMAO:
 
I think it's ironic that, imo, horror movies benefit most from HDR and K's horror catalog is sadly lacking so maybe that's why there are relatively few HDR titles
:)
 
1. The setup is terrible, just an incredibly chaotic experience.
I thought it was great. Couldn't have been easier.

The video and such settings being hidden in a browser is obviously because it's a custom installer device first and foremost.

As they say in the high-end AV installer business, the most dangerous thing you can give the customer is the remote.
 
I thought it was great. Couldn't have been easier.

The video and such settings being hidden in a browser is obviously because it's a custom installer device first and foremost.

As they say in the high-end AV installer business, the most dangerous thing you can give the customer is the remote.
Not agreeing or disagreeing with your comments about installation challenges, but if "it's a custom installer device" then why do they sell it through Best Buy in the USA?
 
Back
Top