• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

4K Cinematic: Movie Availability and Release Order

MikeKobb

Well-known member
◥ ◣ Kaleidescape, Inc.
🏆 1000+ Posts! 🏆
Joined
Oct 22, 2015
Messages
2,743
Location
Mountain View, CA
Greetings all,

There has been some discussion in various threads here on the forum about our new 4K Cinematic™ format, and in particular, questions about which movies are available in 4K Cinematic and the order in which they’re being released. Although I’ve addressed those questions in some of the threads where they’ve been raised, I thought it would be useful to create a new thread specifically to explain this process and make the information easy for everyone to find.

Which movies will be released in 4K Cinematic format?
We are releasing the most popular movies in our catalog, along with new-release films that will be of greatest interest to our customers. For catalog movies, we have an internal goal to release titles down to a target popularity level, and we expect it to take about a year to reach that goal.

Why not all movies?
Every additional format that we release costs a non-trivial amount of money. These films have to be transcoded (which uses CPU time on our encode hosts), tested (which involves both human and automated review), stored indefinitely, and so on. In order to justify that expense, a movie needs to be in enough demand that the investment will be repaid.

This is a moving target. Over time, as our customer base (and the installed base of Strato K players) continues to grow, it will become easier for a title to meet that bar.

Movie XYZ was more popular at the box office than ABC, but you released ABC in 4K Cinematic and not XYZ?
We have very good metrics on which films are popular with our customers. This does not always align with popularity among the population at large.

But surely this movie is super popular. There’s no way it doesn’t meet your requirement!
There are a number of very popular movies that, all else being equal, would have been released in 4K Cinematic already. However, as part of this process, we are backfilling some missing formats (e.g., SDR, Dolby Vision, Atmos audio) where possible, and also updating some 4K titles that have older encodes. In some cases, that means we’re waiting on additional assets from the licensing studio.

We’ve tried not to do piecemeal releases of different versions of the same film (or different installments in a series), so that has caused some titles to be released later than their popularity ranking would otherwise suggest. They’re coming. If it looks like those assets are going to take a bit longer, we may go ahead and release the versions that are already complete.

I hope this helps explain our process as it relates to 4K Cinematic. Let me close by saying that we’ve heard feedback from some people who believe every new title should be released in 4K Cinematic. We appreciate that feedback, but as explained above, that is not viable, at least for now.
 
Thanks for the info @MikeKobb . I do feel that there is a bit of a chance for a self fulfilling prophecy here though as titles that get the 4KC treatment may naturally get some added sales while new titles without 4KC may lag which will make it look like a good choice to not give that title the 4KC treatment. For me personally, I'll be MUCH more likely to purchase a title if it is 4KC. For example, I almost never purchase any HD titles and 99% of my library is only 4K content. That's one of the only reasons I still buy discs occasionally, when Arrow or some other label does a new 4K transfer that is disc only....then I avoid the HD purchase on Kaleidescape. I can envision doing the same thing moving forward for 4KC where I limit my choices to those titles.

I can definitely understand the back catalog being a lower priority for less popular titles, but I was hoping that all new 4K releases would get the 4K Cinematic treatment. In my mind 4K Cinematic is now a unique selling point for Kaleidescape as you can truly say it should always be better than disc. Hopefully with more Strato K sales this policy can change so all new 4K releases get 4KC.
 
I have no sway within the corporate corridors of Kaleidescape, but count me as someone who believes that all 4K releases going forward should also offer a 4KC version, and that catalog 4K’s should get 4KC conversions at a steady rate. 4KC is the new standard. K-scape created it. It’s been a seismic coup and K-scape should FULLY and proudly embrace it. K-scape’s apparent resource limitations as a reason for not adopting this approach as a matter of public policy is a bit of a yellow-flag in my mind.

Instead we get a misty process in a black box. I do hope K-scape can at least commit to putting out 4KC for new releases at the same time as 4K, not via a later update. Many of us make decisions between disc and K-scape for new releases. 4KC definitely tips the scales in K-scape’s favor. I’d hate to see new releases showing vanilla 4K, buy the disc, and then see a 4KC update.
 
I have no sway within the corporate corridors of Kaleidescape, but count me as someone who believes that all 4K releases going forward should also offer a 4KC version, and that catalog 4K’s should get 4KC conversions at a steady rate. 4KC is the new standard. K-scape created it. It’s been a seismic coup and K-scape should FULLY and proudly embrace it. K-scape’s apparent resource limitations as a reason for not adopting this approach as a matter of public policy is a bit of a yellow-flag in my mind.

Instead we get a misty process in a black box. I do hope K-scape can at least commit to putting out 4KC for new releases at the same time as 4K, not via a later update. Many of us make decisions between disc and K-scape for new releases. 4KC definitely tips the scales in K-scape’s favor. I’d hate to see new releases showing vanilla 4K, buy the disc, and then see a 4KC update.
Very well said, I find myself having to decide on which option to purchase, a new release on Kscape or waiting to get the physical disc. Especially if the release offers an object based Dolby Atmos track, or if the disc only offers a 4k disc with no optionally blu ray.
 
I have no sway within the corporate corridors of Kaleidescape, but count me as someone who believes that all 4K releases going forward should also offer a 4KC version, and that catalog 4K’s should get 4KC conversions at a steady rate. 4KC is the new standard. K-scape created it. It’s been a seismic coup and K-scape should FULLY and proudly embrace it. K-scape’s apparent resource limitations as a reason for not adopting this approach as a matter of public policy is a bit of a yellow-flag in my mind.

Instead we get a misty process in a black box. I do hope K-scape can at least commit to putting out 4KC for new releases at the same time as 4K, not via a later update. Many of us make decisions between disc and K-scape for new releases. 4KC definitely tips the scales in K-scape’s favor. I’d hate to see new releases showing vanilla 4K, buy the disc, and then see a 4KC update.
As someone with a K on the way I agree with the desire to have as many titles as possible in 4KC, especially new releases. But how is K acknowledging a resource limitation a yellow flag? If each transcode roughly doubles the storage requirement on their servers, then it's certainly reasonable that they may have to budget the resources they currently have. And while it sucks that their decision tree might not always align with our requests, it's at least a democratic process based on the data they have.

Also genuinely curious what you currently evaluate when deciding to buy the disc of a new release, assuming it doesn't offer something that the K version lacks (e.g., VAR/DV/Atmos). With the changes that were implemented to their encoding process after certain issues were highlighted, I would expect new disc buys to go to almost zero for me.
 
As someone with a K on the way I agree with the desire to have as many titles as possible in 4KC, especially new releases. But how is K acknowledging a resource limitation a yellow flag? If each transcode roughly doubles the storage requirement on their servers, then it's certainly reasonable that they may have to budget the resources they currently have. And while it sucks that their decision tree might not always align with our requests, it's at least a democratic process based on the data they have.

Also genuinely curious what you currently evaluate when deciding to buy the disc of a new release, assuming it doesn't offer something that the K version lacks (e.g., VAR/DV/Atmos). With the changes that were implemented to their encoding process after certain issues were highlighted, I would expect new disc buys to go to almost zero for me.
I wasn't who you replied to, but for me personally, it's primarily the boutique label 4K disc releases that I purchase because they don't have digital rights so the digital 4K (including Kaleidescape) doesn't get released. Those disc buys won't really go away.

But even talking just about 4K releases on Kaleidecape, I often wait until they are on sale for $10 or less if part of a set. But on the 4KC releases, I've been much more willing to pay $15 or $20 for a movie I really like.
 
As someone with a K on the way I agree with the desire to have as many titles as possible in 4KC, especially new releases. But how is K acknowledging a resource limitation a yellow flag? If each transcode roughly doubles the storage requirement on their servers, then it's certainly reasonable that they may have to budget the resources they currently have. And while it sucks that their decision tree might not always align with our requests, it's at least a democratic process based on the data they have.

Also genuinely curious what you currently evaluate when deciding to buy the disc of a new release, assuming it doesn't offer something that the K version lacks (e.g., VAR/DV/Atmos). With the changes that were implemented to their encoding process after certain issues were highlighted, I would expect new disc buys to go to almost zero for me.
I don’t want to be too harsh on K-scape, and didn’t really want to expand on your question because I have ZERO inside knowledge, but the yellow-flag is that one or more of the following may be true: company is being run too lean, inadequate flex/surge capacity, failure to establish increased server capacity in a timely manner, staffing and compensation levels may be internally too imbalanced (management vs technical), financially unable to fully commit to 4KC (Capital lacking despite high margins on hardware? Why?), financially unwilling to commit to 4KC (Profit-taking priority for investors?), flawed launch strategy for 4KC (new 4K standard vs. quality bump that will only be applied to a portion of titles), and/or not committed to delivering the highest quality available for their customers. It’s a yellow-flag instead of a red-flag because none of the above may be the case. However, at the very least, they’re either hamstrung or not fully committed to delivering the very best.

As far as the decision process for buying disc vs K-scape, comparing multiple factors come into play: availability (not everything is available on K-scape), video quality (4KC is the best), audio quality, price, timing (is K getting it early & do I want it enough to pay extra for that), included bonus features, version (not all cuts make it to K-scape). Let me be clear — I’m a huge fan of 4KC. 4KC is something that will cause me to double-dip by repurchasing some of my disc titles in 4KC.
 
I wasn't who you replied to, but for me personally, it's primarily the boutique label 4K disc releases that I purchase because they don't have digital rights so the digital 4K (including Kaleidescape) doesn't get released. Those disc buys won't really go away.
Yep, I get the boutique offerings. So far I've managed to not let the expansion of my library outpace my capacity to watch it, and for now there's plenty available on K to keep me busy for a good while. But it's conceivable that could change for me at some point and those would attract more of my attention.
I don’t want to be too harsh on K-scape, and didn’t really want to expand on your question because I have ZERO inside knowledge, but the yellow-flag is that one or more of the following may be true: company is being run too lean, inadequate flex/surge capacity, failure to establish increased server capacity in a timely manner, staffing and compensation levels may be internally too imbalanced (management vs technical), financially unable to fully commit to 4KC (Capital lacking despite high margins on hardware? Why?), financially unwilling to commit to 4KC (Profit-taking priority for investors?), flawed launch strategy for 4KC (new 4K standard vs. quality bump that will only be applied to a portion of titles), and/or not committed to delivering the highest quality available for their customers. It’s a yellow-flag instead of a red-flag because none of the above may be the case. However, at the very least, they’re either hamstrung or not fully committed to delivering the very best.
Thanks for elaborating, I get where you're coming from now. I guess I'm a little more willing to give them the benefit of the doubt in the early days, especially considering demand for the K player and the new format seems to have genuinely caught them off guard. Choosing to remain hopeful that 4KC for every new release becomes the standard, though perhaps making a little noise about it might just speed that along.
 
Thanks for elaborating, I get where you're coming from now. I guess I'm a little more willing to give them the benefit of the doubt in the early days, especially considering demand for the K player and the new format seems to have genuinely caught them off guard. Choosing to remain hopeful that 4KC for every new release becomes the standard, though perhaps making a little noise about it might just speed that along.
For sure. Gotta stay positive. 4KC will become the de facto standard across the board. No doubt about it in my mind. Just a matter of how quickly it happens now.
 
The digital movie store business isn't for the faint of heart. I'll again point out that absolute titans like Sony ($120B) and Microsoft ($3.79T) have jumped ship on this business. Walmart ($860B) sold Vudu. Apple ($4.7T), Google ($4.1T), and Amazon ($2.79T) are the big players each with hundreds of millions of accounts processing hundreds of thousands of movie purchases everyday.

Meanwhile, Kaleidescape has seen huge initial demand for the Strato K exceeding 1,000 orders. Ok? We're dealing with exponential differences and the fact that the K Store exists is a marvel. So, yes, they have to manage resources and they will for the foreseeable future. We can all decide in which way we disagree with their choices (I mean, isn't that half the fun?) but short of someone injecting a billion dollars into the company we do have to accept K's limitations.
 
Greetings all,

There has been some discussion in various threads here on the forum about our new 4K Cinematic™ format, and in particular, questions about which movies are available in 4K Cinematic and the order in which they’re being released. Although I’ve addressed those questions in some of the threads where they’ve been raised, I thought it would be useful to create a new thread specifically to explain this process and make the information easy for everyone to find.

Which movies will be released in 4K Cinematic format?
We are releasing the most popular movies in our catalog, along with new-release films that will be of greatest interest to our customers. For catalog movies, we have an internal goal to release titles down to a target popularity level, and we expect it to take about a year to reach that goal.

Why not all movies?
Every additional format that we release costs a non-trivial amount of money. These films have to be transcoded (which uses CPU time on our encode hosts), tested (which involves both human and automated review), stored indefinitely, and so on. In order to justify that expense, a movie needs to be in enough demand that the investment will be repaid.

This is a moving target. Over time, as our customer base (and the installed base of Strato K players) continues to grow, it will become easier for a title to meet that bar.

Movie XYZ was more popular at the box office than ABC, but you released ABC in 4K Cinematic and not XYZ?
We have very good metrics on which films are popular with our customers. This does not always align with popularity among the population at large.

But surely this movie is super popular. There’s no way it doesn’t meet your requirement!
There are a number of very popular movies that, all else being equal, would have been released in 4K Cinematic already. However, as part of this process, we are backfilling some missing formats (e.g., SDR, Dolby Vision, Atmos audio) where possible, and also updating some 4K titles that have older encodes. In some cases, that means we’re waiting on additional assets from the licensing studio.

We’ve tried not to do piecemeal releases of different versions of the same film (or different installments in a series), so that has caused some titles to be released later than their popularity ranking would otherwise suggest. They’re coming. If it looks like those assets are going to take a bit longer, we may go ahead and release the versions that are already complete.

I hope this helps explain our process as it relates to 4K Cinematic. Let me close by saying that we’ve heard feedback from some people who believe every new title should be released in 4K Cinematic. We appreciate that feedback, but as explained above, that is not viable, at least for now.
Is there a similar thread for releases of 4K Cinematic Dolby Vision 4:2:2 titles?
 
I certainly understand the need to pick and choose what movies are upgraded to 4KC, just as there is around which movies come to the platform. However, I don’t think every movie should be upgraded solely based on popularity.

I mean I’m the worst offender for upgrading everything to 4K even if I’m not all that interested in the film but there are some which are really not a visual tour de force and it seems like a waste of time. So whilst I’ll do the upgrades, I personally think the resources could be better used focusing on movies which are all about picture quality not Freaky Friday, Mrs Doubtfire, Bridesmaids, 50 First Dates etc. and I say that as someone that owns 3/4 of those!

Perhaps my opinion will change once I get my K but I doubt it since I think the same about standard 4K and HD for those.
 
I certainly understand the need to pick and choose what movies are upgraded to 4KC, just as there is around which movies come to the platform. However, I don’t think every movie should be upgraded solely based on popularity.

I mean I’m the worst offender for upgrading everything to 4K even if I’m not all that interested in the film but there are some which are really not a visual tour de force and it seems like a waste of time. So whilst I’ll do the upgrades, I personally think the resources could be better used focusing on movies which are all about picture quality not Freaky Friday, Mrs Doubtfire, Bridesmaids, 50 First Dates etc. and I say that as someone that owns 3/4 of those!

Perhaps my opinion will change once I get my K but I doubt it since I think the same about standard 4K and HD for those.
Well, to be fair, Mrs. Doubtfire looked incredible, so I'm not sure I agree with classic or beloved films not getting the upgrade. Popularity does make sense for a backlog, but I do wish that they just released an entire series close together rather than strangely having random parts neglected. I will wait to watch until it's all ready, and it's frustrating when some got a very early release (like Cars) and then nothing. I want to watch a series back-to-back, not months apart or out of order. I still think new releases should all be 4KC if the materials are available, as it prevents having to go back and re-doing anything later. It also makes it so that you can buy confidently and watch right away, rather than waiting in the hope it will be upgraded later. For example, I have stalled watching the new Evil Dead movie in the hopes that all the forum attention might get an upgrade.

That said, I really do like how quickly upgrades are happening in general. Having several new 4KC titles each business day has been great. I don't think any of us will be 100% satisfied unless we are personally picking the upgrades, but any communication about the selection process is always welcome.
 
Well, to be fair, Mrs. Doubtfire looked incredible, so I'm not sure I agree with classic or beloved films not getting the upgrade. Popularity does make sense for a backlog, but I do wish that they just released an entire series close together rather than strangely having random parts neglected. I will wait to watch until it's all ready, and it's frustrating when some got a very early release (like Cars) and then nothing. I want to watch a series back-to-back, not months apart or out of order. I still think new releases should all be 4KC if the materials are available, as it prevents having to go back and re-doing anything later. It also makes it so that you can buy confidently and watch right away, rather than waiting in the hope it will be upgraded later. For example, I have stalled watching the new Evil Dead movie in the hopes that all the forum attention might get an upgrade.

That said, I really do like how quickly upgrades are happening in general. Having several new 4KC titles each business day has been great. I don't think any of us will be 100% satisfied unless we are personally picking the upgrades, but any communication about the selection process is always welcome.
To be clear I wasn’t saying they don’t still look good for what they are, just that we aren’t really watching them to be wowed by the visuals, it’s not like Lawrence of Arabia, 2001, Blade Runner, LoTR etc. where you are being wowed by the spectacle of it all. Even from the same era/lead actor, Jumanji and Hook make far more sense IMO.
 
Greetings all,
Why not all movies?
Every additional format that we release costs a non-trivial amount of money. These films have to be transcoded (which uses CPU time on our encode hosts), tested (which involves both human and automated review), stored indefinitely, and so on. In order to justify that expense, a movie needs to be in enough demand that the investment will be repaid.

Would Kaleidescape consider launching a Kickstarter campaign to fund additional resources and infrastructure to accelerate 4K cinematic movie releases?

With ~15 to 20 4KC releases per week and approximately 440 titles out of ~2,880 available 4K movies on Kaleidescape.

I’m sure some home theater enthusiasts would contribute to expanding the 4KC catalog and increasing weekly releases to cover more user libraries.

Would love to hear thoughts on launching such a campaign!
 
Would Kaleidescape consider launching a Kickstarter campaign to fund additional resources and infrastructure to accelerate 4K cinematic movie releases?

With ~15 to 20 4KC releases per week and approximately 440 titles out of ~2,880 available 4K movies on Kaleidescape.

I’m sure some home theater enthusiasts would contribute to expanding the 4KC catalog and increasing weekly releases to cover more user libraries.

Would love to hear thoughts on launching such a campaign!
Honestly? Not trying to be rude but it sounds bonkers. Sales of hardware and content should fund resources based on Ks own business model. If you tried to kickstart such an investment what would people actually get? Unless the commitment is for all movies to be 4kC then everybody is going to get something different based on their personal preferences. Some people might get all the movies they want, others might spend their money only to find none of the movies they are interested in get converted and others get various amounts in between.

Plus what do you do about those that don't choose to kickstart? Are they forever denied access to the new files? Maybe those that do get an exclusive time limited access but for how long? Plus there are elements in terms of time that you may not be able to speed up just by throwing money at it so what increase in the rate of release are people going to get or be expecting for their money?

I can think of several other issues with this suggestion but just the above makes such a suggestion a non-starter. I mean what are we all paying a premium for in the first place? Any suggestion of two-tier quality that is not tied to the purchase price of a hardware or software component is a slippery slope.
 
I show my support by buying the devices and movies. Kickstarter is for starting a business; you can support existing businesses by purchasing their products.
Fair point! Maybe not Kickstarter specifically, but as someone who already owns a player and server, I’d be willing to contribute toward helping Kaleidescape invest in additional resources to accelerate 4KC releases. I’m simply exploring whether there’s a way for existing customers to support faster releases and expand the 4KC catalog.
 
Back
Top