• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

Popcorn Machines

@dinom you got us beat. Ours was new in 2008. Oldest piece of gear in the room (ok, the next room.) Runs like a champ.
 
Decided to give the Whirley Pop a go to do some testing myself. For folks that have them (stainless version), could you share your successful process for making popcorn? E.g. heating up at certain temp, amount of corn, oil, few kernels popping before adding more, etc. Thanks!
 
I've seen some of the tips/tricks, but just wanted more of a step by step if someone could take the time. Nothing eleborate. Maybe @josh or others who have a successful process they use with these poppers. Thanks.
 
I've seen some of the tips/tricks, but just wanted more of a step by step if someone could take the time. Nothing eleborate. Maybe @josh or others who have a successful process they use with these poppers. Thanks.
I'm using the same process with the Popsmith that I used on the Whirlypop.
  • Medium heat. Gas stove, I put the dial at halfway.
  • Add butter flavored coconut oil and 2 or 3 kernals. Whirl y the pop.
  • When the first kernal pops, add the rest of the kernals and seasoning (Flavocol). I don't recall the measurement of kernals.
  • Whirl continuously until you can't anymore - this makes sure as many popped kernals get some of the buttery seasoned flavor.
  • When popping slows to 2 or 3 seconds between pops, turn off heat and empty immediately.
 
Here's my recipe and how I cook healthy, organic, popcorn with the Whirley-Pop stainless steel model using an electric stove. I don't add flavorings or butter - just salt to taste. The organic popcorn I use has plenty of flavor and, in my opinion, does not need any additional flavorings:

Recipe:
1/3 cup Eden Foods Organic popcorn
1 tablespoon Spectrum Organic Canola Oil (just enough oil to cover the bottom of the pot)
Eden Foods Sea Salt sprinkled on top after popping

My detailed Whirley-Pop Popcorn making process:
  1. Remove lid assembly from stored Whirley-Pop
  2. Into pot, pour 1 tablespoon oil
  3. Swirl oil around bottom of pot to coat the entire bottom evenly
  4. Securely attach lid to pot. Ensure the 3 clips are secure
  5. Open 1/2 of lid and pour in all of the popcorn. Close lid
  6. Turn on stove burner medium high to high (On my electric stove with a glass surface, I use a setting of 8 out of 10)
  7. Let stove burner and Whirley-Pop pot heat up for about 1 minute
  8. Hold the wooden handle with one hand, and slowly turn the crank with the other hand for 4+ minutes, or until you only hear an occasional pop or the crank becomes difficult to turn
  9. Turn off heat and quickly remove Whirley-Pop from burner
  10. Open 1/2 of lid and let out remaining hot steam
  11. Carefully, pour popcorn into large bowl
  12. Add salt
Enjoy!

I've found that a slightly higher cooking temperature (8 vs. 6 on my electric glass top stove) slightly speeds up the popping process, but you need to be careful at the end of the popping cycle that you don't burn the oil or popcorn! Due to my electric stove top with a glass surface and the heavy stainless steel Whirley-Pop pot base, after I turn on the burner, I let the pot heat for about 1 minute without cranking in order to first heat the pot. Then I crank for the remainder of the process.

Everyone seems to have a slightly different process to pop their popcorn and everyone seems to have a different recipe. No surprises there!

Enjoy! Please share what your process is!
 
Well, I tried just doing what the Whirley-Pop instructions called for. Put everything in the pot at once with no preheat. Turned on my burner to about medium++ and started turning. My induction burner has 1-9 and then 2 additional higher steps. AI told me to use 7. Once the first kernel popped, the rest went off like firecrackers. I was only making 1/3 cup, but in less than 30 seconds it was done once they started to pop. Both my wife and I agreed that the taste/texture is superior to popsmith. Granted, I may not be a perfect popsmith user. The size of the kernels was also larger and better butter/oil coverage across all kernels. I did also do the preseason that they called for, but not sure that is even needed. I followed @josh instructions for cleaning. Not that bad, but it would be nice if it could be put in the dishwasher like the popsmith. My guess is that the combination of higher heat and increased venting is helping the Whirley-Pop, but who knows…
 
My popcorn machine makes more popcorn that I can eat at one sitting, so I'm frequently left with extra. (It doesn't work very well with the smallest portion packs for some reason.) Anyway, a day or two later, the leftover popcorn is very chewy. I made a marvelous discovery the other day. My little Breville toaster oven has a roasting pan that holds almost exactly one large bucket of popcorn. I fill that pan up, slide it in the Breville set for "Bake" at 250° for five minutes, and hit "Go". The result is perfectly crispy popcorn!
 
Our old air popper from before we got married is finally losing its pop. Luckily I remembered this thread, read all the feedback and ordered a Popsmith. I looked carefully at the Whirley-Pop from @josh 's feedback, and watched the videos posted here. For me I'm looking for the combination of the best quality and the most convenience, even if it costs 20x more than what most people are happy with.

Wait a minute, that sounds kind of familiar!
 
Last edited:
Our old air popper from before we got married is finally losing its pop. Luckily I remembered this thread, read all the feedback and ordered a Popsmith. I looked carefully at the Whirley-Pop from @josh 's feedback, and watched the videos posted here. For me I'm looking for the combination of the best quality and the most convenience, even if it costs 20x more than what most people are happy with.

Wait a minute, that's sounds kind of familiar!
The most important question is: What color combo did you go with?

I love our Popsmith. It's perfect for our needs.
 
The most important question is: What color combo did you go with?

I love our Popsmith. It's perfect for our needs.
Haha! I did spend too much time on that. I was tempted by the limited edition black and gold, but ultimately went with black and chrome, to match my dark seething soul. WITNESS ME!
 
Haha! I did spend too much time on that. I was tempted by the limited edition black and gold, but ultimately went with black and chrome, to match my dark seething soul. WITNESS ME!
I almost went with the gold and black AND I already have the yellow one. That has more to do with my university of choice (Purdue) than anything, but cooler heads prevailed and sticking with just 1 in the household (for now) :D
 
I almost went with the gold and black AND I already have the yellow one. That has more to do with my university of choice (Purdue) than anything, but cooler heads prevailed and sticking with just 1 in the household (for now) :D
Hah! I'll let you know how the black works out. A lot of our kitchen stuff is black and chrome, like my wife's current favorite KitchenAid stand mixer. If it helps, she's now bought three of them. Different colors. So you having two Popsmiths of different colors would not be at all unusual among our people.
 
Last edited:
I just want to give a big thank you to @josh for the extensive popcorn research. :) I've been using your recommended WhirleyPop, Riehle's Goldenrod popcorn, Dutchman's coconut oil, and original Flavacol for a few months now. It literally makes a perfect batch of authentic movie theater popcorn every time! 🍿🍿🍿
 
I use a cheap $20 target Air popper that I bought some 10 years ago. Works like a champ, never a bad batch of popcorn. Just melt butter in the microwave, get your battery powered sea salt grinder, bang. I hate greasy popcorn or popcorn made with some sort of oil in a vat. I can over fill the popper beyond the "serving" line and it just pops it right out. I've tried killing this thing...... 10 years and counting. I'll build myself a fancy plexiglass display case for my air popper before buying a commercial grade popcorn popper. lol
 
I use a cheap $20 target Air popper that I bought some 10 years ago. Works like a champ, never a bad batch of popcorn. Just melt butter in the microwave, get your battery powered sea salt grinder, bang. I hate greasy popcorn or popcorn made with some sort of oil in a vat. I can over fill the popper beyond the "serving" line and it just pops it right out. I've tried killing this thing...... 10 years and counting. I'll build myself a fancy plexiglass display case for my air popper before buying a commercial grade popcorn popper. lol
To each their own... but good popcorn POPPED in oil does NOT mean that it comes out greasy. can be perfectly dry to the touch. To me, air poppers can never recreate the perfect movie theater popcorn, which is why movie theaters never use hot air. Now, it may be HEALTHIER that way, but I'll bet if we put 10 people in front of your air-popped popcorn and my perfectly done oil-popped popcorn, I'd bet 9 out of 10 would pick the oil-popped over the air-popped purely based on taste.
 
To each their own... but good popcorn POPPED in oil does NOT mean that it comes out greasy. can be perfectly dry to the touch. To me, air poppers can never recreate the perfect movie theater popcorn, which is why movie theaters never use hot air. Now, it may be HEALTHIER that way, but I'll bet if we put 10 people in front of your air-popped popcorn and my perfectly done oil-popped popcorn, I'd bet 9 out of 10 would pick the oil-popped over the air-popped purely based on taste.
Come try mine. I haven’t had “good” movie theater popcorn, in ages or ever. The fake crap they sprinkle on or the fake butter…….. that stuff is known to cause cancer…….. but only in California. 🤣
 
Come try mine. I haven’t had “good” movie theater popcorn, in ages or ever. The fake crap they sprinkle on or the fake butter…….. that stuff is known to cause cancer…….. but only in California. 🤣
Living causes cancer in California but they're planning to pass a law to make living illegal.
 
For Whirley experts, looking to improve the results to get the popcorn a bit more crispy. Any suggestions? Thanks.
 
For Whirley experts, looking to improve the results to get the popcorn a bit more crispy. Any suggestions? Thanks.
1. Use less oil. I use 1 tablespoon.
2. Open the 1/2 lid immediately once the popping stops to release any steam.
3. Empty popcorn from popper asap into a large bowl to further allow steam to escape.
 
Back
Top