It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.
You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.
This box goes away for registered users.
I despise variable aspect ratio films. I like when the director can make up their mind.Watched it last night. My daughter was home from college and rewatched it with us. I thought it was excellent.
My only beef is when they switched aspect ratios, the 2.35:1 and wider scenes were locked inside a 16x9 frame. I would have much rather preferred to see the film anamorphic 2.35:1 with the different aspect ratios locked inside of that. When I stretched the content to the 2.35:1 width of my screen, as soon as they went to 16x9 I had content spilling off the screen.
I thought the same thing!!! I loved Crossroads growing up.I enjoyed the movie, but it had some elements from "Crossroads" (1986) and "From Dusk Til Dawn." I watched it in an IMAX theater. Visually, I really appreciated what Coogler was trying to do. I hope he continues to experiment with the format.
Sinners is awesome but it does switch quit a bit. I couldn't tell on my 2:35 screen because with these types of aspect switching movies I just have my JVC switch it to 2:35 aspect and I use the masking feature on the JVC. When the movie switches I can't tell because anything switching over if it would spill over the edges it's blacked out anywayHow often does the aspect ratio switch occur in this movie? I'm having some people over to watch a movie in my theater in Aug and I can't decide between this film and Bad Boys Ride or Die, which I've heard good things about.
I'm using a TV, so does that mean the 2:35 scenes are windowboxed? Or does it mean 2:35:1 scenes have black bars on top and bottom (Like normal) and then it opens up the top and bottom for the taller scenes as needed?when they switched aspect ratios, the 2.35:1 and wider scenes were locked inside a 16x9 frame.
It's delivered in a 16:9 container.Sorry to post in an older thread but this movie is on sale so was going to buy it finally. Needed clarification about it's shifting aspect ratios.
I'm using a TV, so does that mean the 2:35 scenes are windowboxed? Or does it mean 2:35:1 scenes have black bars on top and bottom (Like normal) and then it opens up the top and bottom for the taller scenes as needed?
So if I understand right, then that is basically normal for how any disc would typically handle shifting aspect ratios?It's delivered in a 16:9 container.
The wide shots in Sinners are actually 2.76:1, so they're letterboxed, and the taller scenes fill the screen.
Typically, yes. But digital file playback systems like Kaleidescape and AppleTV don't require the bars to be burned into the file, so for a 2.39:1 4K movie the file can be 4096x1716 without any bars required. If you playback something from AppleTV/iTunes on a Mac, and don't make it full screen, you'll likely see there are no black bars encoded into the file for any title that maintains a single aspect ratio throughout.I guess I am confused by a "16x9 container." Aren't all movies in a 16:9 container and then have black bars as needed?

I think I understand. Thank you. For a TV user, am I correct that this isn’t as much of an issue?Typically, yes. But digital file playback systems like Kaleidescape and AppleTV don't require the bars to be burned into the file, so for a 2.39:1 4K movie the file can be 4096x1716 without any bars required. If you playback something from AppleTV/iTunes on a Mac, and don't make it full screen, you'll likely see there are no black bars encoded into the file for any title that maintains a single aspect ratio throughout.
View attachment 12679
But because the file itself must be one single format throughout the entire movie, a variable aspect ratio film must have black bars for wider aspect ratios.
A disc requires the file to be 3840x2160 no matter what aspect ratio the image is.