• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

NEWS: Strato K Movie Player with 8K capability and new "4K Cinematic" full-chroma & higher bitrate support

I was looking forward to seeing Raiders of the Lost Ark in 4kC, however, it appeared very grainy and not as sharp as I had hoped. The subsequent versions of the series got much better with the later releasees, I noticed similar results with Back to the Future. Hmmm.
Did you try the regular 4K version?
 
Thank for checking!

I recall viewing the HDR10 version of this film before the update on the Kaleidescape, and it appeared superior to the disc version. However, following the Kaleidescape Cinematic Dolby Vision update, all HDR versions of this title appeared inferior to the disc version.

Hopefully Kaleidescape is aware and will rectify
update this issue.



Sent from my iPhone
I have contacted support on this matter. If you haven’t already could I ask that you do now. The more reports the quicker we are likely to see a resolution. Thanks.
 
I just compared Back to the Future 4k HDR10 to 4k Cinematic HDR10.
Both were very good and similar. Certain scenes were softer in Cinematic, although the colors were better and action was smoother.
I differences were subtle.
 
This is the only review (I could find on YouTube) of the K wherein the author attempts to do a side by side comparison between cinematic and non cinematic. Imho, It’s a fun exercise and shouldn't be taken too literally.

Of course, there are a lot of variables involved, plus you cannot get the true representation or illustrations due to equipment/ YouTube constraints. But I still feel it was a decent (and honest) endeavor, all the same.

P.S. If the owner of the media posted below is on the forum and sees this, I hope he’s cool with me posting this out here. Lol.

 
Last edited:
I think that when someone sees an unexplainable difference like the "colors" (seems like brightness to me from the pictures, but "colors" was his word) being different between 4K/4KC, they should look into it more rather than just talking about how Cinematic causes the colors to change. Like, either it's a problem with his setup or there's a real problem in Kaleidescape somewhere; but he seems to think this is normal and expected, which is not the case.
 
If there is nothing wrong with your setup, there must be more going on with Cinematic releases to explain the color or brightness differences. And higher bitrate and 4:4:4 uncompressed chroma is not going to change those parameters, so the encodings must be different from the non-Cinematic ones.
 
You guys might be overthinking it IMHO. I thought the YouTube video was very good. Terminology aside, UpscaledHT and others note a subtle difference with 4KC, which they like. Others may not notice a difference, or prefer regular 4K, but no need to look for a dark lining in the silver cloud of those that feel differently.
 
I look at it differently. I own a Strato E and C, and not a K (yet). The difference (if real) of higher brightness or better colors of the Strato K is almost certainly in the way the content is being encoded, and not due to the increased bitrate or chroma resolutions (neither of those can directly affect that). Therefore, why not make the brighter and better color versions of the content available to all K-scape users, not just the owners of the new Strato K?

And furthermore, does that mean for us users of the Strato E, C or V, the encodings are not accurate or reflective of the mezzanine files provided to Kaleidescape? If there is a difference, even slight, is one more accurate than the other? And if so, which one?

Bitrate and 4:4:4 color resolution can make a visible difference, but not in the way explained in that video above or by others talking about better or brighter colors, etc.. It's just not related in any way technically speaking.
 
Last edited:
I look at it differently. I own a Strato E and C, and not a K (yet). The difference (if real) of higher brightness or better colors of the Strato K is almost certainly in the way the content is being encoded, and not due to the increased bitrate or chroma resolutions (neither of those can directly affect that). Therefore, why not make the brighter and better color versions of the content available to all K-scape users, not just the owners of the new Strato K?
It really just matters which is truer to the mezzanine source and therefore director's intent. One version may appear subjectively better but that doesn't mean it's more accurate. That being said we will never see the source so hard to know. The best we could do is compare to disc and streaming and see if there is a version that seems to be an outlier but we'd still be guesing.
 
I look at it differently. I own a Strato E and C, and not a K (yet). The difference (if real) of higher brightness or better colors of the Strato K is almost certainly in the way the content is being encoded, and not due to the increased bitrate or chroma resolutions (neither of those can directly affect that). Therefore, why not make the brighter and better color versions of the content available to all K-scape users, not just the owners of the new Strato K?

And furthermore, does that mean for us users of the Strato E, C or V, the encodings are not accurate or reflective of the mezzanine files provided to Kaleidescape? If there is a difference, even slight, is one more accurate than the other? And if so, which one?

Bitrate and 4:4:4 color resolution can make a visible difference, but not in the way explained in that video above or by others talking about better or brighter colors, etc.. It's just not related in any way technically speaking.
I believe K-scape has indicated that their new encode recipe would have some positive effect for regular 4K files as well, but the files may become slightly larger.
 
I think that when someone sees an unexplainable difference like the "colors" (seems like brightness to me from the pictures, but "colors" was his word) being different between 4K/4KC, they should look into it more rather than just talking about how Cinematic causes the colors to change. Like, either it's a problem with his setup or there's a real problem in Kaleidescape somewhere; but he seems to think this is normal and expected, which is not the case.
Something appears great to someone (and is excited to share that), there has to be a problem. Wtf?

What’s next…the Bourbon tastes great, make sure you’re not consuming diesel. 🤣🤣
 
In Andrew Robinson's video he claims that 4KC differences are more apparent on displays capable of expanded Rec 2020 like SQD Mini-LED, RGB Mini-LED, and Video Walls.

Jump to:
4:15 Benefits of 4K Cinematic
12:45 Would I buy the Strato K if my TV was...


I'm making no statements as to validity of these claims, the reviewer, etc. and only offering this as another source of input.
 
Something appears great to someone (and is excited to share that), there has to be a problem. Wtf?

What’s next…the Bourbon tastes great, make sure you’re not consuming diesel. 🤣🤣
I guess it's just the engineer in me - there needs to be a technical reason for something to be better, and that reason needs to be a valid one.

But for other folks, if it looks better to them, that's their business.
 
You guys might be overthinking it IMHO. I thought the YouTube video was very good. Terminology aside, UpscaledHT and others note a subtle difference with 4KC, which they like. Others may not notice a difference, or prefer regular 4K, but no need to look for a dark lining in the silver cloud of those that feel differently.

This isn't about feelings or preferences; it's about literal bugginess. The brightness and colors of the image are baked into the master, and aren't part of the encode recipe at all. The encode is about bitrate, and maintaining as much detail as possible through compression while not introducing artifacts.

If anything -- anything at all, whether 4KC or regular 4K or whatever -- is causing the brightness and color to deviate from the master, it's a bug. So either this video is talking about a Kscape bug (whether in 4KC encoding or regular 4K encoding is unclear, but it would have to be in one of them, since they're different and no difference should be possible) or his setup has a problem.

In Andrew Robinson's video he claims that 4KC differences are more apparent on displays capable of expanded Rec 2020 like SQD Mini-LED, RGB Mini-LED, and Video Walls.

His video is good in many respects, but is completely incorrect here. The differences he shows in his video are not possible results of 4KC. In his case, I'm confident he just has his setup wrong (probably in the non-Kscape sources he has hooked up), because the difference he shows are extremely large, and people would have called those bugs out if they were real.
 
In Andrew Robinson's video he claims that 4KC differences are more apparent on displays capable of expanded Rec 2020 like SQD Mini-LED, RGB Mini-LED, and Video Walls.

Jump to:
4:15 Benefits of 4K Cinematic
12:45 Would I buy the Strato K if my TV was...


I'm making no statements as to validity of these claims, the reviewer, etc. and only offering this as another source of input.
I'm thinking he is correct since I use the K with a 110" mini LED.
 
If you compare Moana (the first animated one) 4KC with Moana HDR10 there is a significant difference in color; the 4KC has more 'red' in it. At first I thought I was seeing deeper color as a benefit of 4KC but the skin tones look too red and I wonder what transpired here.
 
This isn't about feelings or preferences; it's about literal bugginess. The brightness and colors of the image are baked into the master, and aren't part of the encode recipe at all. The encode is about bitrate, and maintaining as much detail as possible through compression while not introducing artifacts.

If anything -- anything at all, whether 4KC or regular 4K or whatever -- is causing the brightness and color to deviate from the master, it's a bug. So either this video is talking about a Kscape bug (whether in 4KC encoding or regular 4K encoding is unclear, but it would have to be in one of them, since they're different and no difference should be possible) or his setup has a problem.



His video is good in many respects, but is completely incorrect here. The differences he shows in his video are not possible results of 4KC. In his case, I'm confident he just has his setup wrong (probably in the non-Kscape sources he has hooked up), because the difference he shows are extremely large, and people would have called those bugs out if they were real.

Maybe “perception” is a better word for it than “feeling”? Maybe it’s more of a tiny bump in vividness being called brightness? You and others have far more technical knowledge and a zest for fully understanding the “how’s” and “why’s”.

For me, it’s more like an eye exam where the doctor is switching lenses and asking — which is better, this one, or this one, this one, or that one, etc. It gets subtle and hard to decide. That’s like 4K vs 4KC. Often I give the nod to 4KC. Sometimes I can’t tell the difference. That’s been enough for me to go with 4KC and enjoy it.

Rmarci did a service to all of us by pointing out a shortcoming with 4KC. K-scape should definitely address it. It seems like they are doing so, but we won’t know the full extent until the Q1 ‘27 kOS update.
 
Back
Top