• Thanks for visiting the Kaleidescape Owners' Forum

    This forum is for the community of Kaleidescape owners, and others interested in learning about the system, equipment, services, and the company itself.

    It is run by a group of enthusiastic Kaleidescape owners and dealers purely as a service to this community.

    This board is not affiliated in any way with Kaleidescape, Inc.
    For official technical support, product information, or customer service, please visit www.kaleidescape.com

    You can dismiss this box forever by clicking the "X" in the upper right corner of this message.
  • You are currently in "Guest" mode and not logged in with a registered account.

    The forum is free to use and most of the forum can be used by guests who are not registered....

    ... but we strongly encourage you to register for a full account. There is no cost to register for a full account.

    Benefits of registering for a full account:

    • Participate in the discussions! You must have a registered account to make posts on the forums. You will be able to start your own thread on a topic or question, or you can reply to other threads/discussions.
    • Use the "Conversation" feature (known as "private messaging" on other forums) to communicate directly with any of the other users here.
    • Access the Files area. The "resources" area of the forum contains many "Favorite Scene" and Script files that can dramatically increase the enjoyment of your Kaleidescape system. Go directly to great scenes in your favorite movies, created by other owners, and add automation to playback of your system with Scripts.
    • You won't see this annoying notice at the top of every screen!😊

    It's easy and free to register for the forum. Just click the "Register" button in the upper right corner of this page, and follow the instructions there.

    This box goes away for registered users.

What do you do with your discs?

Edgar

Well-known member
⭐️⭐️PATRON⭐️⭐️
Joined
Oct 29, 2023
Messages
864
Location
North by Pacific Northwest
I’m going through and cataloging all my discs, mostly 4K UHD BD discs and some HD BD discs. I’m buying and downloading my core set of 150 movies, and just cataloging the rest. This is churning out giant table covering stacks of discs. I’m trying to decide what to do with them. When I moved to 4K discs the first time, I purged all the HD discs in large lots on eBay, keeping only core titles and 3D titles. Now that a large part of my collection is steelbooks, I’m thinking they’re worth a lot more than the last time I was at this crossroads. I am thinking I have some options here:

1. Keep only boutique and outlier 4K and HD discs that aren’t on Kaleidescape plus some decorative box sets (Skywalker Saga, Columbia Classics, etc.)
2. Do the above but also keep my core movies in 4K in storage as a sort of backup to the Kaleidescape versions
3. Put it all back in storage because eBay is time consuming

If I were to eBay some volume of this collection, I’m also trying to decide whether to:

1. Bundle all of them into one giant lot
2. Bundle all the steelbooks in one giant lot
3. Bundle the steelbook collections into lots (MCU movies, DC movies, etc.)
4. Sell them all individually

I would likely list them as auctions as compared to buy-it-now, so that I’m done with it faster. Of course that’s a choice, so if anyone recommends buy-it-now pricing, I’d be interested in your thinking.

Okay, back to making dinner.
 
IMG_3836.jpeg
Well some are boxed up, some are now stacked up on my arcade table. I’m honestly attracted to the box them all up option, Raiders style.
 
When I ditched my discs I posted them in lots of 25 or 50 on AVS (or maybe it was Emotiva Lounge?). Lots of guys filling their servers there were interested. There was a guy on AVS the other day looking for 'where can I find a huge collection of blurays?".

I have never been attached to movie discs the way I'm attracted to vinyl. It could be due to my habit of watching assorted scenes and clips after I watch a full movie. Which is the opposite of the reason I listen to music on vinyl - it makes me more likely to listen to a complete album, and not skip from track to track like I do with my Apple Music.
 
Yes, I remember seeing that post on AVS.

I'm somewhat attached to my core movies, but also enjoy rearranging things. I'm leaning toward roughly matching my core movies on K with what I physically display in the built-in on the wall. And put the rest in crates in the storage area on the same level as the theater. Some percentage may get sold off that are duplicates or low priority.

While the intent is move discs in one direction, from display to storage to discard, two have actually moved upstream from storage back to display! Story of my life.
 
I keep discs in binders for easy access, and store the packaging in these:

Even with a large K library, I find discs are needed if you're aiming for the highest quality presentation of all of your favorite films. Boutique labels, 3D Blu-rays, Foreign 4K releases, or just weird Kaleidescape decisions all contribute to the limitation, and K could never overcome all of them (they could spend a little time on that last one though).

I personally favor keeping discs around, especially if the movie is a favorite. You never know what the future may hold, for K or the industry.
 
I'm fairly ruthless. Unless the packaging is interesting or compact, it goes in the bin. The disc(s) goes in a slim-line CD case and the sleeve goes in a an alphabetic file. Naturally the disc is ripped. See below (hopefully), it helps if you don't try it in one go. I will never get rid of my discs, though I note a few have become unreadable. I recently had a purge of all 4x3 and 480P DVDs, bumping them to Blu-Ray or 4K and a general re-rip to get everything in .mkv.
As for indexing I would recommend My Movies, which has a database you can get lost in for hours. You have to give it the disc but it quite quickly asks you if you want add it to the database. Sadly with the demise of Microsoft Media Center there is no longer a Play button, which sort of drove me to K. I expect I'll keep buying discs and indexing them. I love titivating the database.
 

Attachments

Sadly, I gave up on discs a couple years back and sold what I could and recycled the rest. I still have a few special box sets, but only a handful. It has actually been liberating to reduce all the media clutter, but I do get why others aren't like me and still want something physical and tangible.

Andy
 
Selling individually will get you the max dollars but it will also take a long time to get rid of all. If you have thousands of discs, it may take years. Larger lots, get $0.25 to $2 per title on average. I think the sweet spot is 20 to 30 titles in $80-$100 lots. Still a lot of work but you get at least some value for your discs.

Make sure to separate the outliers. There are some OOP discs grabbing a lot of attention. I sold my Al Adamson Masterpiece Collection for $400 the other week (I think I paid $90 before it went OOP). My Columbia Classics Vol 1 set went for a similar price.

Ebay isn’t the best place. They cut 20% plus PayPal and listing fees. That’s too steep in my opinion. Their customer service is awful. I reported many scammers and eBay didn’t ban or remove their listings. I believe they are having trouble attracting sellers (no wonder with such high fees) and they allow anyone and everyone to sell (even with bad feedback).

There are many Facebook physical media groups. I usually find the best buyers there. They are typically movie enthusiasts and physical media collectors. Of course there are many bad apples too but you can usually figure them out from their profiles. (Stay away from new profiles for example).
 
to the best of my knowledge it is actually against the T&Cs with K to catalog, claim D2D and then sell the original disk. Least this was the case a couple of years ago and I kinda got my knuckles wrapped over it. I've still got all my discs. In more plastic boxes than I care to think about :-(
 
to the best of my knowledge it is actually against the T&Cs with K to catalog, claim D2D and then sell the original disk. Least this was the case a couple of years ago and I kinda got my knuckles wrapped over it. I've still got all my discs. In more plastic boxes than I care to think about :-(
Can we confirm this? I understand imported discs are supposed to be kept. Once I own the digital license, why can’t I sell the disc? Am I supposed to toss them in the garbage?
 
to the best of my knowledge it is actually against the T&Cs with K to catalog, claim D2D and then sell the original disk. Least this was the case a couple of years ago and I kinda got my knuckles wrapped over it. I've still got all my discs. In more plastic boxes than I care to think about :-(
It was basically left in a very gray area on here when the reintroduced the program. The T&Cs state you must own the discs at the time of D2D purchase. This to me says you can sell AFTER you’ve completed the D2D conversion, which is what the policy was with VUDU and Ultraviolet/Movies Anywhere when I did all my old DVDs that I didn’t plan to replace with Blu-ray.

You’re purchasing a standalone discounted digital license, so I believe once you’ve completed the transaction you can do what you want with the discs.

Now, I do think it’s a definite violation to catalog everything and sell the discs before paying the D2D cost and completing the transaction.
 
Hopefully @thrillcat is correct. If so and given I've D2D everything I possibly can, anyone in the UK interested in a bucket load of DVDs and Blu-rays? :cool: I literally need the house space back more than anything after majorly downsizing the last few years for personal reasons.
 
Oh wow, I didn’t even think of that. Luckily I just couldn’t bring myself to sell my collection, only my duplicates. Instead I bought 6 more Akro Mills crates to store all my newly sorted discs. Which somehow still counts as fun for me!
 
When I divested myself of physical media for movies and TV series content a while back, I sold what I could on eBay and donated the remainder to my local library. My town and the next over have really great disc catalogs, and we use the library a ton in our family, so I like giving back to them.
 
Will wait for clarification from others, but I was always under the impression that you actually needed to maintain ownership of the physical media... and you couldn't (legally) sell or give away the disc if you still kept the imported image on your K system for playback.

I do see how it's more complicated regarding owning the disc, then paying a (discounted) D2D upgrade price, then selling the disc... since you have now paid a fee to K and the studio for the upgrade... but am interested to hear the official word on this.
 
Will wait for clarification from others, but I was always under the impression that you actually needed to maintain ownership of the physical media... and you couldn't (legally) sell or give away the disc if you still kept the imported image on your K system for playback.

I do see how it's more complicated regarding owning the disc, then paying a (discounted) D2D upgrade price, then selling the disc... since you have now paid a fee to K and the studio for the upgrade... but am interested to hear the official word on this.
I guess it was Jim that posted this but I did verify with VUDU back in the day that after the transaction was complete there was no requirement to keep the discs. That is more of a requirement for “backing up” discs to a NAS vs buying a discounted digital license to the content.

 
In response to Josh's first comment above, he is correct, you are definitely required to maintain possession of the physical discs for as long as you have the content stored in a Kaleidescape system. The following language from the SLA only references DVD and CD discs, but that's because BR discs are required to be verified as present before the persistent copy on the server will play the content.

FROM THE SLA:
In particular, you agree never to load or import or permit someone else to load or import a commercial DVD or CD or replica thereof onto your Kaleidescape System unless you rightfully own the DVD or CD. You further agree that if you sell, give away, lend, or otherwise transfer ownership or possession of a commercial DVD or CD (other than by destroying it or loaning it to Kaleidescape), you will immediately delete from your System all Content previously loaded or imported from that DVD or CD.

ATTACHMENT A (to the SLA) addresses use of the Kaleidescape Movie Service (the K Store):
Kaleidescape may offer upgrades to higher quality for eligible DVDs and Blu-ray discs. Such offers are only available for titles that have been legitimately purchased and are presently owned by you. Kaleidescape reserves the right to periodically re-verify possession of discs used to qualify for such offers. Kaleidescape reserves the right to withhold these offers, or to limit or cancel your access to the title if we reasonably believe such title does not meet, or no longer meets, the requirements set forth in this paragraph.

So it can easily be argued there's a requirement to own, and possess, the physical discs in both instances, whether we're using Premiere systems and "importing" disc based content to create a persistent copy, or obtaining discounted digital content "downloaded" from the K Store, if the discounts are being granted based on our ownership of a physical disc, whether that discount is based on a D2D offer, an upgrade to a higher resolution, or the purchase of a different edition, then based on the language above we are required to own and continue to possess the content that the discount was based on when it was granted. As a trial lawyer for 15+ years, that's the way I read it, but reasonable minds my differ.


Jim
 
So it can easily be argued there's a requirement to own, and possess, the physical discs in both instances, whether we're using Premiere systems and "importing" disc based content to create a persistent copy, or obtaining discounted digital content "downloaded" from the K Store, if the discounts are being granted based on our ownership of a physical disc, whether that discount is based on a D2D offer, an upgrade to a higher resolution, or the purchase of a different edition, then based on the language above we are required to own and continue to possess the content that the discount was based on when it was granted. As a trial lawyer for 15+ years, that's the way I read it, but reasonable minds my differ.
I could see that being a tack the studios take. Similar to upgrade pricing on software, the new version is technically tacked-on to the old one, so you are required to keep both, and only a fresh retail copy breaks the chain. Not that I expect it to be the common practice.
 
Back
Top